Who is tighter on grading Morgan Dollars?

Tdec1000

Our host or ATS? Now I know there is a lot of deciding factors and over the years it probably has flip flopped. But for blast white examples who is tougher? For original NT coins who is tougher?

dbcoin

our host is tougher. Buy the keys in PCGS. Especially if you are buying in MS65 or higher

themaster

The blue-fish is tightest.

Have a Great Day!
Louis

ColonelJessup

MrEureka

roadrunner

The short list is jotting down those few series, and grade breakdowns where ATS is tighter. Last I could figure out, they were slightly tighter on MS66 Bust halves. This doesn't include additional descriptions like Full Steps, etc. where the 2 services don't have the same standards.

That was my short list.


roadrunner

PonyExpress8

Prior to the past 2 years I would say our host. Over the past 2 years it's a tossup IMHO. Both have been consistent, strict and fair.

COALPORTER

I dpn't think it has ever flip-flopped.

BlindedByEgo

On the whole, the market seems to indicate our host.

SeaEagleCoins

the strictest I have seen are the dealers I am trying to sell some to