Home› Sports Talk
Options

Greatest Cardinals?

CollectorAtWorkCollectorAtWork Posts: 859 ✭✭✭
in Sports Talk
I'm not a Cards fan, but was curious to hear what the consensus was on the great Cards players, especially in light of the Pujols situation. Here's my list, but I could have missed some.

(1) Stan Musial
(2) Albert Pujols
(3) Bob Gibson
(4) Rogers Hornsby
Babe Ruth Master Set
Lou Gehrig Master Set
Non-Registry Collection
Game Used Cards Collection

Comments

  • Options
    HallcoHallco Posts: 3,627 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Lou Brock comes to mind...also, I know a lot of Cards fans that have a huge place in the franchise for Ted Simmons. Probably not in the "best player" category, but I would guess a top 5 in fan popularity.
  • Options
    markj111markj111 Posts: 2,921 ✭✭✭
    Ozzie and Dizzy belong on the list. I would expect that Pujols will rank #1 by the time he retires.
  • Options
    ernie11ernie11 Posts: 1,908 ✭✭✭✭✭
    With all due respect to Pujols, Stan Musial was the greatest Cardinal.
  • Options
    lanemyer85lanemyer85 Posts: 1,317 ✭✭✭
    1. Musial
    2. Hornsby
    3. El Hombre de humano sustantivo hormona

    Hornsby was markedly more valuable than Gibson. #13 all-time in Win Shares ahead of DiMaggio and Mike Schmidt.

    Hornsby - career 127.8 WAR*
    Gibson - career 85.6 WAR*

    * wins above replacement
  • Options
    jivanjivan Posts: 1,009 ✭
    KURT WARNER
    always looking for 1969 graded basketball
  • Options
    markj111markj111 Posts: 2,921 ✭✭✭


    << <i>With all due respect to Pujols, Stan Musial was the greatest Cardinal. >>




    I'll leave that argument to the Cardinal fans. Both were/are terrific.
  • Options
    johnny1976johnny1976 Posts: 440 ✭


    I might put Joe Medwick in there.
  • Options
    johnny1976johnny1976 Posts: 440 ✭


    Sorry thought of one more, Pepper Martin.
  • Options
    cardbendercardbender Posts: 1,831 ✭✭
    Other greats:

    Enos Slaughter
    Ted Simmons
    Curt Flood

    Musial was the best. When I think of the best Cardinals player ever,
    he immediately comes to mind.
  • Options
    PiggsPiggs Posts: 1,934 ✭✭✭✭
    I'm only voting for Frankie Frisch because I have this cool picture of him. He spent 8 years with the Giants and the rest of his 19 with the Cardinals. He's probably not good enough for top 4 of course but looking at his stats, he only struck out more than 20 times in a season two times! That is amazing! That's the only reason I pick him near the top of the list. Doug




    image
  • Options
    bman90278bman90278 Posts: 3,453 ✭✭✭
    Doug, that's a sweet photo you have there!

    brian
    My Dodgers Rookie Cards Project
  • Options
    theczartheczar Posts: 1,590 ✭✭
    Stan will ALWAYS be #1. ALWAYS.
  • Options
    BABERUTHJOEDIMAGGIOBABERUTHJOEDIMAGGIO Posts: 470 ✭✭
    probably Stan Musial but a close second Rogers H.
    maybe one day they might say Albert P.
  • Options
    DialjDialj Posts: 1,636 ✭✭
    Musial
    Hornsby
    Dizzy Dean
    Puljois
    Gibson
    "A full mind is an empty bat." Ty Cobb

    Currently collecting 1934 Butterfinger, 1969 Nabisco, 1991 Topps Desert Shield (in PSA 9 or 10), and 1990 Donruss Learning Series (in PSA 10).
  • Options
    mr3holesinonemr3holesinone Posts: 444
    Holes-in-One
    1. 7-17-81 Warrenton GC Driver 310 yards 7th Hole (Par 4)
    2. 5-22-99 Warrenton GC 6 iron 189 yards 10th Hole
    3. 7-23-99 Oak Meadow CC 5 iron 180 yards 17th Hole
    4. 9-19-99 Country Lake GC 6 iron 164 yards 15th Hole
    5. 8-30-09 Country Lake GC Driver 258 yards 17th Hole (Par 4)

    Collector of Barber Halves, Commems, MS64FBL Frankies, Full Step Jeffersons & Mint state Washington Quarters
  • Options
    mr3holesinonemr3holesinone Posts: 444
    Red Schoendienst, Jack Buck and Mike Shannon all served and have been with the Cardinals for decades each one of them. Announcers aren't often thought of as part of the team though they are an integral part of the make up we see and hear when listening and viewing games.

    A few favorites of mine not likely to make the list are Jack Clark, Ted Simmons & Lee Smith. I got to play basketball a few times with Lee Smith and Andy Van Slyke and as great athletes they could really hoop it up.

    A sure top 5er would have been Steve Carlton. I'm sure it's wishful thinking but we may have an extra flag or two atop the stadium had he stuck around.
    Holes-in-One
    1. 7-17-81 Warrenton GC Driver 310 yards 7th Hole (Par 4)
    2. 5-22-99 Warrenton GC 6 iron 189 yards 10th Hole
    3. 7-23-99 Oak Meadow CC 5 iron 180 yards 17th Hole
    4. 9-19-99 Country Lake GC 6 iron 164 yards 15th Hole
    5. 8-30-09 Country Lake GC Driver 258 yards 17th Hole (Par 4)

    Collector of Barber Halves, Commems, MS64FBL Frankies, Full Step Jeffersons & Mint state Washington Quarters
  • Options
    HeritageAddictHeritageAddict Posts: 3,266
    Two ex-Cardinals that I enjoyed watching the most are Jim Edmonds and Scott Rolen....they both played hard, old school ball players for sure.
    Cut Auto Cards 4 sale

    My Registry Sets
  • Options
    jivanjivan Posts: 1,009 ✭
    orlando cepeda,roger maris,joe garagiola,larry fitzgerald
    always looking for 1969 graded basketball
  • Options
    WinPitcherWinPitcher Posts: 27,726 ✭✭✭
    It's Stan Musial and then everyone else.


    Good for you.
  • Options
    wrestlingcardkingwrestlingcardking Posts: 4,555 ✭✭✭✭
    Sad to see Carpenter retire, but he was a great one that should be honored in ballpark village. Will never be a HOFer but he pitched with a lot of guts and 2011 would not have happened without him.
    BUYING Frank Gotch T229 Kopec
    Looking to BUY n332 1889 SF Hess cards and high grade cards from 19th century especially. "Once you have wrestled everything else in life is easy" Dan Gable
  • Options
    MGLICKERMGLICKER Posts: 7,995 ✭✭✭
    Gibson.
  • Options
    DIMEMANDIMEMAN Posts: 22,403 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Steve Carlton was a Philly and Roger Maris was a Yankee,

    I agree with Stan at the top and Gibson would be close to the top. He dominated hitters.
Sign In or Register to comment.