RYK gave me an idea, lets play if you will guess the price guide if there were one!

Realone

Here are three coins for which no price guide exists, lets playguess what these three should be valued at:

1827 10c JR-1 MS64 NGC

1825 10c JR-2 F-15 PCGS

Undated 50c S AU58 PCGS

ChrisRx

Fifty Dollars.

STONE

I'll start the bidding at $100/each

Feliz Navidad!

llafoe

I see 70 cents?

Unknown

This content has been removed.

STONE

<< <i>I see 70 cents? >>


I see $1.20 and Two Heads

JRocco

Just that 27 in 64
Not to mention the "uniqueness" of her...

A lot of money

Merry Christmas Realone

Unknown

This content has been removed.

STONE

<< <i>In a ll seriousness my point is that how do you value a coin where no price guides exist and there are only one auction price from approx 10 years ago for 2 of the 3. Yet dealer's will price these, but based on what? Pretty thinly traded. >>


Realone, you know it's all about DEMAND and POPULARITY. Uniqueness and pedigree help, but the first two stand the test of time.

If a collector wants a unique coin bad enough, he/she will poney up to buy it.
OR, the owner can ask for stronger money which may not EVER find a buyer.
Does this mean that the owner of said coin is outpricing the market? Not necessarily, it's just that he values the coin greater than anyone else!

Price guides are essentially worthless - is there one for the art market?

Unknown

This content has been removed.

QuarterCollector

It all depends on how much it would take you to part with them.

Tom

BigE

I think something is wrong with one of my eyes--------BigE

crazyhounddog

<< <i>Here are three coins for which no price guide exists, lets playguess what these three should be valued at:

1827 10c JR-1 MS64 NGC

1825 10c JR-2 F-15 PCGS

Undated 50c S AU58 PCGS
>>



These are very cool coins! But I have no idea what the value would be. I know for sure they're rare, and I would love to own any of them....

rld14

I have no clue whatsoever on the CBDs, but a WAG on the Barber Half would be $7-10k if it showed its' face at Heritage.

PawPaul

i would guess as a trio - more then 100,000 $

speety

<< <i>i would guess as a trio - more then 100,000 $ >>



I woulda guessed more like $20,000 - as a set. I guess that proves the point of the OP

STONE

<< <i>

<< <i>i would guess as a trio - more then 100,000 $ >>



I woulda guessed more like $20,000 - as a set. I guess that proves the point of the OP >>


I'd take'm all for $20k

They're probably in the $70k range - imo

ColonelJessup

<< <i>

<< <i>In a ll seriousness my point is that how do you value a coin where no price guides exist and there are only one auction price from approx 10 years ago for 2 of the 3. Yet dealer's will price these, but based on what? Pretty thinly traded. >>


Realone, you know it's all about DEMAND and POPULARITY. Uniqueness and pedigree help, but the first two stand the test of time.

If a collector wants a unique coin bad enough, he/she will poney up to buy it.
OR, the owner can ask for stronger money which may not EVER find a buyer.
Does this mean that the owner of said coin is outpricing the market? Not necessarily, it's just that he values the coin greater than anyone else!

Price guides are essentially worthless - is there one for the art market? >>

coindudeonebay

<< <i>Fifty Dollars.
>>

Yea, definitely fifty dollars, of course, judge wapner is on at 3!!

I would say about 20k.

Eagleguy

Those are so cool! I love the third one. I couldn't even guess how to value them.

JH

Patches

I'd pay $1,000 for the two side Barber Half

lava

These off-the-chart freaks might be assumed to go for big bucks, and I thought that myself when a freak came up for auction. I assumed it would go for moon money. It sold for around $200. I think I bid $2,500. I have enjoyed it ever since. Granted it is technically cleaned, but I don't think that accounts for the low bid. My guess is that people were focusing on other coins and it slipped through the cracks.

MFH

<< <i>I'd pay $1,000 for the two side Barber Half >>



$1,000 Face value in Gold Buffalo .9999 ... more like it.

I could see the Half going for 20K by itself to a well
heeled collector.

Realone - you're thinking of selling, huh ??