Milk Dud Poppage - Some Pictures

Dboneesq

I had these Full Boxes of Milk Duds hanging around for many years. I wanted to get them slabbed to protect them and I finally got around to sending them in to be graded. They all look real nice, so I have no idea how they are graded. Must have been a small crease or wrinkle in the lower graded ones. I did see a very small wrinkle in the Mays, so I figured it would get a mid grade.

Line # Item # Cert # Grade Description Type Country
1 1 17225899 NEAR MINT 7 1971 MILK DUDS COMPLETE BOX 1 FRANK HOWARD Card US
2 1 17225900 EXCELLENT 5 1971 MILK DUDS COMPLETE BOX 3 WILLIE MAYS Card US
3 1 17225901 NEAR MINT-MINT 8 1971 MILK DUDS COMPLETE BOX 13 DAVE JOHNSON Card US
4 1 17225902 EXCELLENT 5 1971 MILK DUDS COMPLETE BOX 14 BUD HARRELSON Card US
5 1 17225903 MINT 9 1971 MILK DUDS COMPLETE BOX 15 ROY WHITE Card US
6 1 17225904 EXCELLENT 5 1971 MILK DUDS COMPLETE BOX 23 TOMMY JOHN Card US
Total Items: 6
Date Received: 9/10/2010

.........................Here is one of the lowest graded.....................................................and the highest graded.

tyweb1

Nice job on the 9. Finally some poppage.

fiveniner

Be happy my freind,how many of these get submitted in the first place?I think you did good.

thedutymon

Morning,

Looks like the Milk Dud Grader finally got back from vacation!!!

YeeHah

Neil

Dboneesq

<< <i>Morning,
Looks like the Milk Dud Grader finally got back from vacation!!!
YeeHah
Neil >>



HAHA ... that's what I was thinking Neil. Many people have said that the best chance to get a quick turnaround is to keep the cards in your submission similar. I never did that before, so I tried this time. SIX cards all from the same year and series. Can't get much more basic than that. It still took over one calendar month for them to be graded. (To those who are ready to write something, yes, I know there is a 45 BUSINESS DAY turnaround guarantee.)

Dboneesq

Pictures added at top.

BPorter26

Doug, Nice stuff. I'm still looking for a Clemente box

Ironmanfan

I gotta get me a Brooksie one of these days

IMF

thedutymon

Afternoon,

I am going to be real interested when I get my 12 back if I can tell the difference between the NM-MT 8, NM-MT+ 8.5 and the two GEM MINT 10's. I think the two 10's had several crease points that had never been folded like the Boxes were taken off the production floor before the machine inserted and opened/squared them up.

Neil

Dboneesq

Neil,

Some of these are so hard to tell the difference. The reason I put up the Mays is because you can see an indentation to the right of his nose, just to the left of the vertical brown line. However, between Frank Howard (7), Dave Johnson (8) and Roy White (9) I would have had no idea which one got the "7" and which one the "9" if I didn't see it in the holders.

GOOD LUCK with your sales of the Milk Duds. I'd like to see what they go for.

heritage

Nice Job. I only need 6 more boxs for a complete set of milk boxs.
What did you sub under? Tall Boys?

corvette1340

I thought you said these were full boxes? I see no milk duds.

fiveniner

<< <i>I had these Full Boxes of Milk Duds hanging around for many years. I wanted to get them slabbed to protect them and I finally got around to sending them in to be graded. They all look real nice, so I have no idea how they are graded. Must have been a small crease or wrinkle in the lower graded ones. I did see a very small wrinkle in the Mays, so I figured it would get a mid grade.

Line # Item # Cert # Grade Description Type Country
1 1 17225899 NEAR MINT 7 1971 MILK DUDS COMPLETE BOX 1 FRANK HOWARD Card US
2 1 17225900 EXCELLENT 5 1971 MILK DUDS COMPLETE BOX 3 WILLIE MAYS Card US
3 1 17225901 NEAR MINT-MINT 8 1971 MILK DUDS COMPLETE BOX 13 DAVE JOHNSON Card US
4 1 17225902 EXCELLENT 5 1971 MILK DUDS COMPLETE BOX 14 BUD HARRELSON Card US
5 1 17225903 MINT 9 1971 MILK DUDS COMPLETE BOX 15 ROY WHITE Card US
6 1 17225904 EXCELLENT 5 1971 MILK DUDS COMPLETE BOX 23 TOMMY JOHN Card US
Total Items: 6
Date Received: 9/10/2010

.........................Here is one of the lowest graded.....................................................and the highest graded.
>>



Nice!!!!!!!

Dboneesq

<< <i>I thought you said these were full boxes? I see no milk duds. >>



Tommy ... before they slab the boxes they roll over them with a steamroller ... all the milk duds get flattened and are hidden between the panels. If you can pick one of these up that are graded "PSA 1" at a cheap price, you can always open it up if you get hungry.

HeritageAddict

Nice stuff Doug, but I really wish you had a Bob Gibson in that lot for me.

lsutigers1973

I went to Walmart today just to buy a big Halloween bag of Milk Duds. None had baseball players on them.

Dboneesq

<< <i>Nice Job. I only need 6 more boxs for a complete set of milk boxs.
What did you sub under? Tall Boys? >>



Thanks ... since the only items I sent in on the sub were 6 Milk Duds Boxes I did not bother to indicate "size".

Dboneesq

<< <i>Nice stuff Doug, but I really wish you had a Bob Gibson in that lot for me. >>



Doran, would you like this one?



If so, you will have to find the person that owns it! LOL

HeritageAddict

Thanks Doug, you can expect a priority mail box full of dog poop next week.