Would you do this trade?

GeoffEighinger

I was offered Chipper Jones for Bronson Arroyo

+ I am leading the league in Wins but need hitting

- I just lost Carlos Silva to the DL today

+ I have Roy Halladay, Mike Leake, R.A. Dickey, Jon Garland Clayton Richard (and Silva)


Chipper is old but Bronson isn't exactly a star?

I would be replacing Juan Uribe with Chipper and Juan kinda had a hot streak going.

lbcoach20

Uh....I wouldn't do it. Even though Bronson's ERA is over 4 he is 11-6. Plays on a good team that has a good chance of winning everynight. Chipper is batting .250 with 8 hr and 43 RBI. That is very average to me and you can probably pick up a free agent such as Casey Blake who have better numbers than Chipper IMO. By the way, I checked out your Manning blog. Very cool. I have a game used bat of his from '77-'79 labeling period. And I went to college with Matt Underwood and was in the same frat as him.

Scott

GeoffEighinger

Nice.

I didn't do it. Thanks for the advice.

Manning rules. I never got to watch him play but I listen to him and Matt every night. They may not be the best, but Rick is Slick and Matt is from my hometown.