1909 & 1910 $2 1/2 Indians.........grade opinions please.

SUMORADA

Thank you in advance........

STONE

Genuine - Cleaned
AU-55

doh

'10: harshy cleaned AU50
'09: AU53

PerryHall

They both appear to be AU55 with the first one having a possible cleaning.

mozin

I learned years ago to only buy TPG little Indians. Way too many are counterfeit, and many of the raw ones will not grade with the TPG.

I cannot grade the coins from pictures.

LanLord

<< <i>I learned years ago to only buy TPG little Indians. Way too many are counterfeit, and many of the raw ones will not grade with the TPG.

I cannot grade the coins from pictures. >>

Probably good advice. Everyone that says those are harshly cleaned, I believe, are forgetting that they have no rim to protect the surface. A single slide across a table will cause hairlines.

I don't agree that they are cleaned, but without seeing in hand, I can't tell.

coinguy1

They both look genuine and AU55 at a minimum, to me. I'm open to the possibility, but not convinced that the first one has been cleaned.