My newp David Hall Numismatic Group Morgan...

jmj3esq

Picked this up this week at a local B+M. I think it could go MS66. What you think?

Justacommeman

Another self slabber...........

MJ

divecchia

It's a nice looking coin especially the back...

Donato

Connecticoin

Good shot at 66. I like those old David Hall holders, though.

Meltdown

<< <i>Good shot at 66. I like those old David Hall holders, though. >>



I agree. If you were to send it in inside that holder, it may just upgrade for that reason alone.
I would guess it would only grade 65 if you sent it in raw.

etexmike

<< <i>Another self slabber...........

MJ >>



Yep, they come and they go.


Mike

DrPete

It's the BIG ONE from years ago.

savoyspecial

.

BigE

Dont the people who check in the coins cut them out before the graders even see them?

jmj3esq

Dont the people who check in the coins cut them out before the graders even see them?

Yes, BigE, they do.....But are you, or I, or anyone else for that matter, watching?

Unless they have 3rd parties watching is there any assurance but their own word?

SeattleSlammer

66 surely looks possible

CaptHenway

FWIW, I offered a coin holdered like that to Mr. Hall himself at a show in the very late 80's (I think it was the 1989 Central States show in Overland Park, KS), and he very politely told me that those grades were no longer applicable.

Justacommeman

<< <i>FWIW, I offered a coin holdered like that to Mr. Hall himself at a show in the very late 80's (I think it was the 1989 Central States show in Overland Park, KS), and he very politely told me that those grades were no longer applicable. >>


TD, what did you read into that? Interesting.................MJ

BigE

I think I would send it in then, that plastic it's in my damage it sooner or later and you would be able to see it better, maybe get the 66 and have a fun wait in the meantime Good luck with it Joe--------------BigE

CaptHenway

<< <i>

<< <i>FWIW, I offered a coin holdered like that to Mr. Hall himself at a show in the very late 80's (I think it was the 1989 Central States show in Overland Park, KS), and he very politely told me that those grades were no longer applicable. >>


TD, what did you read into that? Interesting.................MJ >>



Only that he did not wish to buy it at the grade indicated. Nothing more.

Connecticoin

<< <i>FWIW, I offered a coin holdered like that to Mr. Hall himself at a show in the very late 80's (I think it was the 1989 Central States show in Overland Park, KS), and he very politely told me that those grades were no longer applicable. >>



Yes, but that was 1989.

Most of the David Hall coins I have seen are now conservative relative to today's PCGS standards.

Barbercoin

Beautiful!!!

blueifalcon

If it wasn't for the reverse she'd probably be a 64, because of the cheek problems mainly. She is a doll though...

jmj3esq

Believe me there are no cheek issues. Its my bad photo along with the bad lighting and the mark just right of the nose is on the flip.