My 1909-VDB 67 RD ReSubmit? (No Photo)

DRUNNER

OK, I most likely have few coins warranting any "+" resubmission from a value standpoint (perhaps quite a few would make it, but the "+" premium in the Price Guide is quite close to non "+").

Still, I have a 1909-VDB 67 RD that has been CAC'd and appears (well, to me) high end. The value differential from standard to "+" is $1500 - $2250. My 2 questions:

1.) Is this the type of coin that PCGS is encouraging for resubmission with the Big One?

2.) How was the $750 price differential arrived at (accepting that the basic Price Guide has certain limitations in accuracy anyway in a real-world scenario)? Could it be previous market transactions for PQ coins?

Thanks for your consideration and ponderings . . .

Drunner

illini420

It was always my understanding that the PCGS Guide prices were already for PQ examples of PCGS graded coins... the bad ones traded at discounts to the Price Guide in most cases.


I took a quick look at the + prices posted so far (which are based on what I don't know), but they do seem very dealer friendly and extremely optimistic!!!

I've been in the hunt for a PQ '09 VDB in 67RD for a little while and was willing to pay $1500 for a nice one, maybe a little more for a really special example... and I've seend them sell from $1100 up to about $1800 in the past year or so... but to now say a PQ example is now worth $2250???? Based on what??? We'll see... again, having those sort of numbers in a price guide helps dealers as they can now justify moon money prices.