Need help determining value!

vladguerrero

Hey guys, a friend of mine has a couple multiple signature signed programs. They were obtained from a Ump that worked the games. He's wondering what to think re: value and if he can get help identifying the signatures (some in better shape than others). Comments and thoughts on value are welcomed. For signature ID I'll number the pics and keep a running updated list of the names on each page. I'm going to upload 15 pics, one of the signatures is Munson. Thanks for everyone's help!

PIC #1 (Cookie Rojas, Steve Mingori)


PIC #2 (Dave Moates, Tony Oliva, Cal Ripken Sr, Nellie Briles, Rico Petrocell, Grant Jackson, Brooks Robinson, Dave Johnson, Yogi Berra, Phil Roof, Orlando Ramirez?, Dick Williams, George Brett, Phil Rizzuto, Paul Blair + 2)


PIC #3 (Marty Pattin, Tony Solaita)


PIC #4 (John Mayberry)


PIC #5 (Phil Rizzuto, Brooks Robinson, Dick Williams, Jack McKeon, Al Dark,Tony Kubek)

vladguerrero

PIC #6 (Bill Campbell, Harry Caray, Curt Gowdy, Tony Kubek, Maury Wills, Monte Irvin+ ???)


PIC #7 (Carlton Fisk, Whitey Herzog, Chuck Tanner, Bill Virdon, Sparky Lyle, Dick Allen, Norm Cash, Rick Burleson)


PIC #8 (John Mayberry, Paul Blair, Ed Brinkman, Jim Hunter, Reggie Jackson, Thurman Munson, Cookie Rojas)


PIC #9 (Rollie Fingers, Brooks Robinson, Carl Yaz, Ken Holtzman, Catfish Hunter)


PIC #10 (Nolan Ryan)

Smuggo

Some of the sigs in pic #6 are Bill Campbell, Harry Caray, Curt Gowdy, Tony Kubek, Maury Wills and Monte Irvin
It also looks like the auto that is potentially the most valuable (Munson) may have had a couple drops of water impair it as well
overall a nice piece, I can't help with the value

vladguerrero

PIC #11 (George Brett)


PIC #12 (scorecard)


PIC #13 (Tom Seaver, + ?)


PIC #14 (Don Sutton)


PIC #15 (Don Sutton, Dick Wise, Hank Aaron, Willie Stargell, Jack Billingham)

vladguerrero

<< <i>Some of the sigs in pic #6 are Bill Campbell, Harry Caray, Curt Gowdy, Tony Kubek, Maury Wills and Monte Irvin
It also looks like the auto that is potentially the most valuable (Munson) may have had a couple drops of water impair it as well
overall a nice piece, I can't help with the value >>



Yeah, anyone know if it was raining the day of this game? lol Thanks for the help! Can anyone else ID some sig's or share a guess at value?

Nathaniel1960

$100-200 per program, because the condition is unfortunately just dreadful. I could see an auto cuts collector bumping those prices up a bit, particularly for the Munson. One issue would be the ability to get most of the rare and HOF sigs cut off without damaging other sigs (e.g. on the opposite sides of the same page).

I just don't see this is a collectible on its own b/c of condition.

MooseDog

The program cover - PIC #2 clockwise from the left side...

Dave Moates
Tony Oliva
Cal Ripken Sr
Nellie Briles
Rico Petrocell
Grant Jackson
(can't really see the two upside downlight ones)
Brooks Robinson
Dave Johnson
Yogi Berra
Phil Roof
Orlando Ramirez ?
Dick Williams
George Brett
Phil Rizzuto
Paul Blair

MooseDog

PIC #5

Jack McKeon on top
Al Dark near Babe's face
Tony Kubek by Aaron's armpit

Can't see the one by Musial

PIC #6
One by Monte Irvin is Dave McKay

PIC #7
Norm Cash at the top
Rick Burleson at the bottom

PIC #8
That is indeed an in-person vintage Reggie Jac... signature

PIC #9
I see Ken Holtzman on the left and part of a Catfish Hunter on the right.

vladguerrero

Great work moose!

Yankees001

The Thurman Munson signature alone would sell for over $200. I've seen Munson Cut's sell for $400-500 +

The program with out the Munson $100-200 is probably close.

The program with the Munson $400-500 if Authenticanted much more. The other signatures are rather common.