Which one of these cards do you think is the most visually appealing? Jack Nicklaus 81 Golf

thenavarro

I have these two Jack Nicklaus 1981 Donruss Golf autographed cards, and I am going to be selling one. I'm tyring to decide on which is the most visually appealing, and that is the one I'll be keeping for my collection. Just wondering what your thoughts are as to which of these, in your opinion, is more visually appealing.

I'm leaning toward keeping the PSA one and selling the JSA one, but just wanted to see if y'alls thoughts concurred with mine.

The PSA one doesn't have the tilt cut that the JSA one has, but the JSA one has better corners and a fuller, bolder sig.

Smuggo

I like the bottom with the thinner marker.

bman90278

I'd like to see a better scan of the lower card...The top one is a higher end card, but I like the sig and centering better on the lower card. I'd go for the PSA card if it were me.

Brian

corvette1340

I like the sig better on the PSA card but it goes over part of Jack's face. Tough call, either way, nice autos.

Brick

PSA +4

lsutigers1973

Mike, when you decide which one to keep, PM me a price on the other one.

hookem

I would keep the JSA card. Just my personal pref! If you keep the PSA send me your price for the JSA.

Hook'em

thehallmark

Bottom one looks great. Tilt on the JSA card makes me dizzy.

72skywalker

The PSA looks the best to me.

MantleMarisFordBerra

<< <i>I like the sig better on the PSA card but it goes over part of Jack's face. >>



My first thought as well.

thenavarro

Thanks for the opinions. I'm going to keep the PSA and I sold the BGS/JSA one to Bill.

Hook'em, Bill (LSUTigers1973) had first dibs as he had already contacted me.

Thanks,

Mike