Newp 1928 Peace - Opinions Welcome

RCDB

If someone could link Ebay auction #370339989546, I would appreciate it very much. I'm sure that I got a great deal $ wise and I feel the color will be great. I'm hoping some luster will be peaking out through the toning. Upgrade potential seems minimal with the marks on the reverse. I wouldn't take it out of the old Anacs holder anyway. I haven't seen too many 28s that look this original. What do you all think? Thumbs up or down?

coinman420

here ya go

RCDB

Thanks. One of these days I'll learn how to do that.

anablep

Nice date, nice rim tone and great older ANA holder...

Peaceman

Let us know how it looks in hand. Eagle shoulder tells me 58... I used to have about 80 of them about 10 years ago. I was buying up all of the 64's I could at $ 480. They all went bye bye at $ 1200....

chucknra

I was thinking in the AU 55-58 range. Nice coin though and I'd keep it in the old holder.

Connecticoin

<< <i>Let us know how it looks in hand. Eagle shoulder tells me 58... I used to have about 80 of them about 10 years ago. I was buying up all of the 64's I could at $ 480. They all went bye bye at $ 1200.... >>



Same here. I actually had a snipe set at $610 for that coin, then took it off as I thought the risk of a 58 was too high. So RCDB should thank me for saving him $150. To show his appreciation he should get rid of that hideous icon.

CoinGuy42

I say thumbs up. I think you bought a nice coin at a very good price...no down side.

lkeigwin

I like it too, though I'm not big on toned Peace dollars. It's very nice. Good job!

I think in hand the coin may prove it's not a slider.
Lance.

Rollerman

From what I can tell from the images, I'd say thumbs up. Couple that with the fact that I usually agree with the grading on these old ANACS holders, I'd say thumbs way up!
Pete

joebb21

I think you did great!
good job