Any worth Grading ??

Smittys

Downtown1974

Absolutely! Very nice collection!

jeffcbay

I need that '57 Robinson, but yours may be too nice for what I'm looking for. I just want a low grade one for my raw collection.

If it were me, I would grade each and every one of those cards. Nice collection!

waxpack

I'd get them all graded... old is gold.

OAKESY25

personally I would not, unless you want them in psa 4-5 slabs

also, the post cereal will only grade authentic.. they do not have enough border showing

nice collection though

Pigs

I think you should grade most of them but, I agree you'll get "authentic" on the Post cards because the border is cut into. Being picky the Aaron would probably get a low grade MC and the '58 Musial would not grade very high. Nice cards though. Doug

Karb

If they are for your own personal collection and not for investment then I say go for it. Nothing wrong with protecting them.

ElToroLoco

Nice collection, grade them all in the next group sub!

NickM

Don't get the Posts graded - they will come back Authentic. I wouldn't get the '60 Aaron (it will get a MC qualifier), the '61 Yankees Team Card, the '58 and '61 All-Stars, the '60 multi-player cards, or the '62 Spahn graded. I might pass on grading the '60 Gibson and '59 Mantle as well. I doubt grading would add value to any of those cards.

Nick

diamondman

here are the six I would get graded: 57 B. Robinson, 57 Koufax, 57 Bunning, 59 Mantle, 61 Mays, 61 Spahn. The rest leave raw. JMHO

ThoseBackPages

Yes, they are all worth grading.

storm888

I agree with the folks who noted some defects, but I would prolly
still grade them all on the next group sub.