NFL Award Winners Key Card Set Additions

recbball

These will be the cards I ask PSA to add to the following sets unless anyone in the sets objects:

NFL Annual Rushing Leaders - Chris Johnson ?

NFL AP Comeback Player Of The Year - 2000 SP Authentic #118 Tom Brady

NFL AP Defensive Player Of The Year - 1998 SP Authentic #23 Charles Woodson

NFL AP Defensive Rookie Of The Year - 2009 Topps Chrome #TC130 Brian Cushing

NFL AP MVP - Peyton Manning's '98 SP Authentic #14 is already in the set

NFL AP Offensive Player Of The Year - ? Chris Johnson

NFL AP Offensive Rookie Of The Year - ? Percy Harvin

All these cards are RCs according to Becketts web site, are not auto or patch cards, and have a print run at 999 or over.


Cris Johnson and Percy Harvin have multiple RCs that would quallify:

Chris Johnson
2008 Topps Chrome #TC186
2008 Stadium Club #117 (print run 1799)
2008 Donruss Elite #120 Chris Johnson (print run 999)
2008 Select #348 (print run 999)

Percy Harvin
2009 Topps Chrome #TC155
2009 Donruss Classics #232 Percy Harvin (print run 999)
2009 Donruss Elite #179 (print run 999)
2009 Score Inscriptions #383 (print run 999)

If you have an interest in one of the sets these players are included in let me know which card you prefer.

JasP24

Tom looks good, although I'm clueless on the 2008/2009 stuff.

Jason

perkdog

I just picked up a lot of 4 of these- 2008 Topps Chrome #TC186 Chris Johnson- off Ebay Raw for $16 shipped, I will get them graded, assuming one gets a 10 did I do OK? I havnt a clue to the value of this card, I put a bid on it for the heck of it and won.

recbball

Hi Jason,
I double checked the newer cards and found alternates for the following:
2008 Donruss Elite #120 Chris Johnson/999 RC
2009 Donruss Elite #179 Percy Harvin /999 RC

Hi Paul,
I bought a 2008 Topps Chrome #TC186 Chris Johnson PSA 10 for 10 bucks a couple of months ago. That being said I think the price will go up after this season's performance.

recbball

See top post for edit on Percy Harvin and Chris Johnson.

JasP24

<< <i>
Cris Johnson and Percy Harvin have multiple RCs that would quallify:

Chris Johnson
2008 Topps Chrome #TC186
2008 Stadium Club #117 (print run 1799)
2008 Donruss Elite #120 Chris Johnson (print run 999)
2008 Select #348 (print run 999)

Percy Harvin
2009 Topps Chrome #TC155
2009 Donruss Classics #232 Percy Harvin (print run 999)
2009 Donruss Elite #179 (print run 999)
2009 Score Inscriptions #383 (print run 999)

If you have an interest in one of the sets these players are included in let me know which card you prefer. >>



I would prefer the most valuable rookie amongst the ones you have posted here that qualify. I don't know which those are, but that would be my preference. Whoever is requesting these additions to PSA needs to do the legwork to figure that out, otherwsie should wait until we know rather than adding the wrong card. Would also like the card to mirror the HOF RC set, a set which the majority of collectors who would be interested in these particular sets probably already collect. Would help with #1, recruiting members to join these sets, and #2, would help consistency by using the BEST rookie of each player rather than 5 different sets requiring 5 different rookies of the same player. That doesn't help build the popularity of the set or the cards in it.

Just my opinion of course,
Jason

Davemri

Recieved the poll for Johnson today.... Which one should we choose??

Dave

Davemri

There are 7 rookie cards to choose from. Please review the list below and reply with your of #1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 or 7.



1. 2008 TOPPS #351

2. 2008 TOPPS CHROME #TC186

3. 2008 TOPPS KICKOFF #183

4. 2008 TOPPS LETTERMAN #68

5. 2008 TOPPS MAYO #290

6. 2008 TOPPS ROOKIE PROGRESSION #207

7. 2008 TOPPS TRIPLE THREADS #108








I assume Topps Chrome, but does anyone have any evidence to show that is outsells the others??

Dave

recbball

I chose Topps Chrome.
Not sure why these cards weren't listed:
2008 Stadium Club #117 (print run 1799)
2008 Donruss Elite #120 Chris Johnson (print run 999)
2008 Select #348 (print run 999)

I think the Dunruss Elite might be worth more.

These cards would not quallify for the future HOF RCs or rc HOF sets
4. 2008 TOPPS LETTERMAN #68 (print run 419)
7. 2008 Topps Triple Threads #108 Chris Johnson JSY AU RC (print run 89)

JasP24

<< <i>I chose Topps Chrome.
Not sure why these cards weren't listed:
2008 Stadium Club #117 (print run 1799)
2008 Donruss Elite #120 Chris Johnson (print run 999)
2008 Select #348 (print run 999)

I think the Dunruss Elite might be worth more.

These cards would not quallify for the future HOF RCs or rc HOF sets
4. 2008 TOPPS LETTERMAN #68 (print run 419)
7. 2008 Topps Triple Threads #108 Chris Johnson JSY AU RC (print run 89) >>



This is why playing with these brand newbie cards are so dangerous. It's hard to keep PSA straight with the older easy stuff...Get into cards released a year ago, or even this year for that matter...GOOD LUCK! And with the advent of SO MANY like sets, now they've confused the sets and are getting ready t oadd Chris Johnson to the All-Time Rushers!

I guess my stance when all these sets were being added wasn't as out of left field as some thought..THIS my friends is WHY...Been on the Registry for 7 years now, this latest turn of events doesn't surprise me one bit...We basically asked for it....lol

Jason