A pretty decent sized planchet flaw on this 1922 Peace dollar

braddick

This can just about be seen from across the room! Neat die cracks too.

coinkid855

It looks like a nice strike through to me, not a planchet flaw.



-Paul

braddick

<< <i>It looks like a nice strike through to me, not a planchet flaw.



-Paul >>



I originally thought so too, but PCGS disagrees with us.
(Just returned to me yesterday.)

coinkid855

That sucks.


I don't understand PCGS's policy of not grading planchet flawed coins. That's how the coin came out of the mint! It's essentially a mint error, so why bag it?





-Paul

morgandollar1878

Did you submit the coin under the mint error service or just a regular submission???

braddick

<< <i>Did you submit the coin under the mint error service or just a regular submission??? >>



Admittedly, under the normal, economy service.
Would I have been better off submitting it differently?

Peaceman

Yep, That can only be holdered in a "mint error" holder....

JJM

man, thats a train wreck, resub it or just enjoy it !