Opinions on auto? - Aaron, Mathews, Crandall, Ad{ock

bigjaco

Contimplating for my '58 pennant project and Ad{ock and Mathews look ok to me; but don't know Aaron and Crandall that well yet. Opinions welcome.

(if some one buys this it would probably be a good thing; cause last thing I need is to spend more on cards --- so feel free!)

RipublicaninMass

crandall looks good to me

vladguerrero

that aaron is going to be a tough call without holding it in hand to see the sig in better lighting... psa/dna quick opinion?

MooseDog

All look Ok except the Aaron, which looks like a common secretarial. If that passes, I've got a signed program for the game he hit #715 that will go up in value...

NickM

Crandall looks like a PSA/DNA one I have. Aaron has changed his signature over time, but it doesn't look right to me.

Nick

bigjaco

Thanks for the opinions guys. How reliable is the psa/dna quick opinion? I don't mean that negatively but if you get a "Likely Genuine" is there a very high success rate that all four are in fact genuine. I've now been looking at Aaron signatures till my eyes bleed. I can't tell. Always figured on just buying one pre-authenticated.

I should probably be passing if there is any doubt at all.

Nathaniel1960

One of my all time favorite cards....Braves were incredibly popular that year, which is an accomplishment for a Milwaukee based team.