Why the drastic difference ...

SilverHaze

between Gray Sheet "bid-ask" price & PCGS "Daily Price Guide" price for a 1922 Saint graded MS65? I have one listed below gray sheet and I emailed a prospective buyer who responded with "PCGS lists the coin for $4,500, so your price is not below wholesale." Boy... do I feel stupid! Usually, the PCGS price guide is much higher than gray sheet (or is it grey sheet?), was I wrong by stating it was below wholesale?


Thanks... any insight appreciated!

RyGuy

The PCGS price guide is flawed.

airplanenut

For what it's worth, here are the last handful that sold at Heritage:

8/2/09
65 NGC $2,875.00
65 NGC $3,450.00
65 NGC $4,312.50
65 PCGS $3,220.00
65 PCGS $3,220.00
65 PCGS $3,450.00
65 PCGS $3,593.75

7/12/09
65 PCGS $2,990.00
65 PCGS $3,220.00
65 PCGS $3,105.00

SilverHaze

<< <i>For what it's worth, here are the last handful that sold at Heritage: >>



Thanks Jeremy, I appreciate it!



Dave