All Time Saints Registry
rexvos
Posts: 3,304 ✭✭✭✭✭
I see the set went live:
Cards that need to be added asap:
1983 Topps Stan Brock Rookie
1984 Topps USFL Bobby Hebert RC
1987 Topps Eric Martin RC
1988 Topps Dalton Hilliard RC
2001 Topps Chrome Deuce McAllister
after these we can consider others like
1983 Topps Bruce Clark RC
Cards that need to be added asap:
1983 Topps Stan Brock Rookie
1984 Topps USFL Bobby Hebert RC
1987 Topps Eric Martin RC
1988 Topps Dalton Hilliard RC
2001 Topps Chrome Deuce McAllister
after these we can consider others like
1983 Topps Bruce Clark RC
Looking for FB HOF Rookies
0
Comments
Sam
Thanks for your comments rexvos and Sam.
When I made an outline of what would be the checklists for the all-time Saints, Falcons and Seahawks sets I set the mark at a min. of three pro-bowl appearances and player had to play a good portion of their career ith that team. I have lived my whole life in Chicago and there is no way I could know the history of these three teams the way I know the Bears history. I tried to keep the checklists simple for these three teams so they would appeal to more than a few collectors. I have also chosen the most valuable RC for each player that has a min. print run of 999 and does not include auto or relic cards.
I would vote for all the cards you both have brought up. I think you have to use the best RC of each player to make the set desireable for more collectors. The 2001 Topps Chrome Deuce McAllister is definately the way to go.
I'll check back later, time to watch the Bears game
Tom
All-Time Saints
Danny Abramowicz 1-time first-team All-Pro
Andy Livingston 1-time Pro Bowler
Tony Baker 1-time Pro Bowler
Jake Kupp 1-time Pro Bowler
Tom Dempsey 1-time Pro Bowler & 1-time first-team All-Pro
Archie Manning 2-time Pro Bowler
Chuck Muncie 3-time Pro Bowler
Wes Chandler 4-time Pro Bowler & 1-time first-team All-Pro
Henry Childs 1-time Pro Bowler
Tom Myers 1-time Pro Bowler
George Rogers 2-time Pro Bowler & 1-time first-team All-Pro
Rickey Jackson 6-time Pro Bowler
Brian Hansen 1-time Pro Bowler
Morten Andersen 7-time Pro Bowler & 3-time first-team All-Pro
Rueben Mayes 2-time Pro Bowler
Hoby Brenner 1-time Pro Bowler
Brad Edelman 1-time Pro Bowler
Dave Waymer 1-time Pro Bowler
Sam Mills 5-time Pro Bowler & 1-time first-team All-Pro
Vaughan Johnson 4-time Pro Bowler
Eric Martin 1-time Pro Bowler
Dalton Hilliard 1-time Pro Bowler
Pat Swilling 5-time Pro Bowler & 2-time first-team All-Pro
Joel Hilgenberg 1-time Pro Bowler
Renaldo Turnbull 1-time Pro Bowler & 1-time first-team All-Pro
Tyrone Hughes 1-time Pro Bowler
Willie Roaf 11-time Pro Bowler & 3-time first-team All-Pro
Wayne Martin 1-time Pro Bowler
Eric Allen 6-time Pro Bowler & 1-time first-team All-Pro
Joe Johnson 2-time Pro Bowler
Ricky Williams 1-time Pro Bowler & 1-time first-team All-Pro
Joe Horn 4-time Pro Bowler
Kyle Turley 1-time first-team All-Pro
La'Roi Glover 6-time Pro Bowler & 1-time first-team All-Pro
Keith Mitchell 1-time Pro Bowler
Mark Fields 2-time Pro Bowler
Sammy Knight 1-time Pro Bowler
Deuce McAllister 2-time Pro Bowler
Michael Lewis 1-time Pro Bowler & 1-time first-team All-Pro
LeCharles Bentley 2-time Pro Bowler
Mitch Berger 2-time Pro Bowler
Drew Brees 3-time Pro Bowler & 1-time first-team All-Pro
Jammal Brown 2-time Pro Bowler & 1-time first-team All-Pro
Will Smith 1-time Pro Bowler
It'll be a fun set to put together, with a lot of characters too. Maybe we should vote in Az Hakim, since he got us our first playoff win ;-)
1969 Topps Danny Abramowicz
1974 Topps Tommy Myers (I think
1989 Score Wayne Martin
1969 Topps Dan Abramowicz #36
1970 Topps Jake Kupp #196
1973 Topps Del Williams #277
1974 Topps Tom Myers #94
1977 Topps Henry Childs #68
1977 Topps Tony Galbreath #257
1982 Topps Dave Waymer #413
1983 Topps Stan Brock #110
1983 Topps Bruce Clark #111
1984 Topps Jim Wilks #307
1984 Topps USFL Bobby Hebert #62
1985 Topps Hoby Brenner #102
1987 Topps Eric Martin #276
1988 Topps Dalton Hilliard #57
1989 Score Wayne Martin #248
1990 Fleer Jim Dombrowski #185
1990 Pro Set Frank Warren #219
1990 Pro Set Joel Hilgenberg #588
1990 Score Renaldo Turnbull #615
1994 Ultra Joe Johnson #213
1999 Bowman Chrome Aaron Brooks #199
2001 Topps Chrome Deuce McAllister #258
2006 Bowman Chrome Marques Colston #29
Although Dave Waymer only had one Pro Bowl appearance, consider that people with 5 more interceptions or less include Deion Sanders, Mel Renfro, Larry Wilson, Donnie Shell, Yale Lary, Jake Scott, and Ken Houston(one more). He is tied or has more interceptions than Herb Adderley, Willie Wood, Lemar Parrish, Jack Christiansen, Jimmy Johnson, Mike Haynes, and Roger Wehrli.
<< <i>I would also strongly consider Craig Heyward as an addition also.
Although Dave Waymer only had one Pro Bowl appearance, consider that people with 5 more interceptions or less include Deion Sanders, Mel Renfro, Larry Wilson, Donnie Shell, Yale Lary, Jake Scott, and Ken Houston(one more). He is tied or has more interceptions than Herb Adderley, Willie Wood, Lemar Parrish, Jack Christiansen, Jimmy Johnson, Mike Haynes, and Roger Wehrli. >>
I agree on Waymer. I always liked that Coke head, Heyward is not a bad idea either.
Sam
<< <i>Waymer was the best corner the Saints ever had. Period. I have no problem with Ironhead. Cosetta emailed me today and said she would send out a poll in mid September. If you guys want to email her to throw more in there please be my guest. I actually want lots of cards on here, because the Saints are my team and it will make it more fun and interesting.
Sam >>
I agree, I woulder if they would put my 1986 McDonalds Frank Wattlet in there. I loved that guy.
I also really liked Jeff Groth, but not sure if he quite would make the cut.
<< <i>if you are going to add Colston, the best choice is the SP Authentic >>
The SP Authentic for this card only has a print run of 750. If Colston has a great career this card would not be included in the HOF sets where the cutoff for print run is 999. The 2006 Bowman Chrome would be the choice. Well I think Colston is a great receiver and I wish the Bears had him I think it's too early in his career to be labeled an all-time great.
<< <i>Well, we are talking about the Saints here... three years of greatness is an all time great for us. >>
2 above average years would probably suffice.
<< <i>
<< <i>if you are going to add Colston, the best choice is the SP Authentic >>
The SP Authentic for this card only has a print run of 750. If Colston has a great career this card would not be included in the HOF sets where the cutoff for print run is 999. The 2006 Bowman Chrome would be the choice. Well I think Colston is a great receiver and I wish the Bears had him I think it's too early in his career to be labeled an all-time great. >>
Your right, I thought it had a run of 999 or 1250.
When you are setting up All Time Team sets, do you include coaches/execs? If so, do you include their rookie cards as players or coaches? Are there rules for this or is there at least some uniformity?
<< <i>When you are setting up All Time Team sets, do you include coaches/execs? If so, do you include their rookie cards as players or coaches? Are there rules for this or is there at least some uniformity? >>
PSA only allows RCs recognized by Beckett. So if you were to start an All-time team where the coach's RC was back in his playing days and you wanted to add a card of him as a coach I don't know if PSA would allow that.
For example when I started the All-Time Bulls set I included Phil Jackson's '72 Topps card.
Tom
PLAYOFFS?
<< <i>
PLAYOFFS? >>
pass on him.
1. 1969 Topps Dan Abramowicz #36 YES
2. 1970 Topps Jake Kupp #196 YES
3. 1973 Topps Del Williams #277 NO
4. 1974 Topps Tom Myers #94 YES
5. 1977 Topps Henry Childs #68 YES
6. 1977 Topps Tony Galbreath #257 YES
7. 1982 Topps Dave Waymer #413 YES
8. 1983 Topps Stan Brock #110 YES
9. 1983 Topps Bruce Clark #111 NO
10. 1984 Topps Jim Wilks #307 NO
11. 1984 Topps USFL Bobby Hebert #62 YES
12. 1985 Topps Hoby Brenner #102 YES
13. 1987 Topps Eric Martin #276 YES
14. 1988 Topps Dalton Hilliard #57 YES
15. 1989 Score Wayne Martin #248 YES
16. 1990 Fleer Jim Dombrowski #185 NO
17. 1990 Pro Set Frank Warren #219 NO
18. 1990 Pro Set Joel Hilgenberg #588 YES
19. 1990 Score Renaldo Turnbull #296 YES
20. 1994 Ultra Joe Johnson #213 YES
21. 1999 Bowman Chrome Aaron Brooks #199 NO
22. 2001 Topps Chrome Deuce McAllister #258 YES
23. 2006 Bowman Chrome Marques Colston #29 YES
Sam
Sam
<< <i>By the way, I was the one who put Aaron Brooks on the list. I thought long and hard about it. While I personally think he is a tool, he was our starting QB for 5 and 1/2 years and was the first QB to actually WIN a playoff game for us. I figured it would at least be worth a vote. Of course, I voted against him...
Sam >>
I hate him so much.
Sam
<< <i>I think this is going to be a really fun set to collect. Especially with 25-30 cards. It will be fun to track them all down. BTW, how long before they make the changes?
Sam >>
not sure. I did have a 1988 Topps Hilliard PSA 9 pop today though. I really want it in a 10, but I bought a lot of 29 of them and the 9 was only one I had that was submittable.
Whoever did not vote these guys in should not have been allowed a vote.
And Rexvos, I agree again... Eric Freaking Martin? C'mon!!! He's not there, but Wes Chandler is in? Wes caught 182 passes for the Saints in just over three seasons, with 15 TD's. Martin caught 532, with three seasons of over 1,000 yards and 48 TD's. I love Wes Chandler, but his contributions to the Saints were small compared to Eric Martin. I was really looking forward to this being a 25-30 card set with the best players all represented. But I think it has turned out to be a list of the players people were most familiar with. The way the registry has it where each person gets a vote doesn't mean much to me. What are the qualifications? So, if my neighbor's kid decides to register one card in the set, he gets a vote? The more I look at it the more I am considering just not bothering with it and deleting my set. It's just foolish. I am having a hard time going after what I truly believe to be "About 60% of the All-Time Saints".
<< <i>And Tommy Myers and Wayne Martin not on the All-Time team? Good grief. That's the best defensive back and the best defensive lineman not making it. Martin played eleven seasons with the Saints and had ten or more sacks FIVE TIMES. This includes one season with 15.5 and another with 13. He is the second leading sacker in Saints history behind Rickey Jackson. He also recovered quite a few fumbles, and started every game for the Saints for nearly ten seasons until he retired. La'Roi Glover was a great player for the Saints for basically two seasons. He had many of his best seasons in Dallas. How is he there and not Wayne?
And Rexvos, I agree again... Eric Freaking Martin? C'mon!!! He's not there, but Wes Chandler is in? Wes caught 182 passes for the Saints in just over three seasons, with 15 TD's. Martin caught 532, with three seasons of over 1,000 yards and 48 TD's. I love Wes Chandler, but his contributions to the Saints were small compared to Eric Martin. I was really looking forward to this being a 25-30 card set with the best players all represented. But I think it has turned out to be a list of the players people were most familiar with. The way the registry has it where each person gets a vote doesn't mean much to me. What are the qualifications? So, if my neighbor's kid decides to register one card in the set, he gets a vote? The more I look at it the more I am considering just not bothering with it and deleting my set. It's just foolish. I am having a hard time going after what I truly believe to be "About 60% of the All-Time Saints". >>
You can still collect the one's you want to. I would be more upset if I had to buy 10 cards I really don't care about.
Also, I think it might annoy other collectors if you made the set as big as you like. Would not make that twice the size of an average all-time team set right now?
Raw: Tony Gonzalez (low #'d cards, and especially 1/1's) and Steve Young.
Sam
<< <i>I don't know about other teams sets. I don't care about them. I only am a fan of the Saints. It's not that I wanted a huge amount of cards. It is just that I think if you are going to only have 15 or 18 or whatever, they should be the absolutely most deserving players. And I understand how people are. If you don't follow the Saints as your team ,you don't know who a guy like Tommy Myers is. He played in one Pro Bowl and never played on a winning team. He retired 28 years ago and is largely forgotten. Eric Martin is pretty much an unknown as well, despite the fact that he is the Saints All-Time leader in receptions, receiving yards, and yards from scrimmage. But I just think we should get it right. I like Dalton Hilliard a lot. And really all of the guys selected. But to pick Dalton Hilliard or Wes Chandler, who were great for a year or two at most, and then overlook your all-time leader in three huge statistical categories seems strange. Honestly, if we were only picking ten guys, Eric Martin should be one of the ten. I haven't looked at the other All-Time teams, but I'm going to guess that most of them have the all-time leader in yards from scrimmage on the team. But I have noticed that most of the people collecting the set also collect the All-Time teams from all of the others, so alas I am one of the only Saints guys voting. So the rest of you don't want to have to add a bunch of guys you aren't big fans of to a set when you are also collecting 31 other teams. I can respect that. Just a little disappointed. Maybe I'll have to start up Eric Martin, Tommy Myers, and Wayne Martin player sets as my own tribute.
Sam >>
it infuriates me that Eric Martin is not in as a Saints fan, on a side note.
this guy should be in but this is his only card:
Sam
PSA 10 2001 TOPPS CHROME 258 DEUCE McALLISTER ROOKIE REFRACTOR $50.00 dlvd
PM me or e-mail at jabeduco@yahoo.com. PayPal accepted.
Jason
according to my values and my needs. Nothing holds dominion over me, I stand alone as the ruler of my life.
The Saints All Time Team needs to add John Hill, Wayne Martin, Tommy Myers, and Eric Martin as they are listed as starters on the All Time Team that the Saints announced today.
Also cut Chuck Muncie and Wes Chandler as both did most of their damage with the Chargers.
<< <i>I don't know about other teams sets. I don't care about them. I only am a fan of the Saints. It's not that I wanted a huge amount of cards. It is just that I think if you are going to only have 15 or 18 or whatever, they should be the absolutely most deserving players. And I understand how people are. If you don't follow the Saints as your team ,you don't know who a guy like Tommy Myers is. He played in one Pro Bowl and never played on a winning team. He retired 28 years ago and is largely forgotten. Eric Martin is pretty much an unknown as well, despite the fact that he is the Saints All-Time leader in receptions, receiving yards, and yards from scrimmage. But I just think we should get it right. I like Dalton Hilliard a lot. And really all of the guys selected. But to pick Dalton Hilliard or Wes Chandler, who were great for a year or two at most, and then overlook your all-time leader in three huge statistical categories seems strange. Honestly, if we were only picking ten guys, Eric Martin should be one of the ten. I haven't looked at the other All-Time teams, but I'm going to guess that most of them have the all-time leader in yards from scrimmage on the team. But I have noticed that most of the people collecting the set also collect the All-Time teams from all of the others, so alas I am one of the only Saints guys voting. So the rest of you don't want to have to add a bunch of guys you aren't big fans of to a set when you are also collecting 31 other teams. I can respect that. Just a little disappointed. Maybe I'll have to start up Eric Martin, Tommy Myers, and Wayne Martin player sets as my own tribute.
Sam >>
I agree w/ you on the team sets and the player selections.
Super Bowl XXVIII: Buffalo Bills vs Dallas Cowboys -
Running back Emmitt Smith rushed for 132 yards and 2
touchdowns earning Super Bowl MVP honors as the Cowboys
defeated the Bills 30-13 to win their second consecutive NFL
title.