Canadian grading help

jfoot13

I need a little help grading these Unc dollars..
1st is 1954 beautiful toned obv and a blast white semi P/L rev
2nd is a nicely toned 1936 nice unc but has a more subdued luster not the flash of the 54
these dynolites are nice but don't due toning justice

/











thanks for any help
Ken

DoubleEagle59

ICCS grading would be about:

1954: ms62/ms63

1936: au58

1960NYGiants

63 + 55

canadacolornut

Agree on the 54 but where are you seeing AU on the 1936?

Flatness of the moustache, tip of the ear, what?

I see MS 61 or 62, just not picking up the wear.

jfoot13

thanks for the help
Ken

1960NYGiants

CCN - there are significant flat spots on the eyebrow, mustache, chin and shoulder of obv. Same is true for rev. if you compare it to the 54 notice the flatness of the trapper's shoulder, chest and hands along with lack of detail on the canoe.