Raw card show pickups-Guess the grade-GRADE IN

leadoff4

I'm hoping the Flood can pull a 6 and I think the Cardenal would be a 9 but the lower left probably knocks it to an 8. Slim pickins'(vintage wise) at the local show today. Thoughts on the grades... Backs are clean on both cards.

OAKESY25

curt flood = miscut

cardenal 7.5

fattymacs

Flood 6

Cardenal 8 ( 8.5 if corners are as sharp as they look)

Stone193

Hi Neal

The Jose is a nice card - looks like a 7+ to 8+.

The Flood is diamond cut - I've heard people say if slight, it could find its way into a holder - but could be returned as 'miscut' - check the 'square'on the card.

mike

Pigs

Neal-- Because the centering is good on Jose that could be a 7 or 8 with a 7.5 possible. I wouldn't send in the Flood because of the MC. Like you said it's getting harder to find nice vintage at shows.

RonBurgundy

Miscut and PSA 8. Burgundy.

leadoff4

I agree, sure as heck better be a miscut after all the others they've graded that way that don't even look miscut! Cardenal is an easy 8 I think.

leadoff4

Well, here's the update. Only sent in the '66 Cardenal. Guess I was right this time. Boy are they tough on these '71s!!

Mefer

<< <i>Well, here's the update. Only sent in the '66 Cardenal. Guess I was right this time. Boy are they tough on these '71s!!
>>



I think the down grade to a 7 on the 71 was due to the centering. It otherwise looks to have at least 8 corners.

Matt