Cards you wish PSA would grade - Let's see 'em

redlegs

I thought this would be an interesting topic. For me, I would love to have my Kenwood Plaza Johnny Bench graded, however, I received it back stating that it is not cataloged. I own three of these.

rbdjr1

1984 Topps Nestle

mikeschmidt

<< <i>1984 Topps Nestle >>



Oh come now, I have four 1984 Topps Nestle graded Mike Schmidt cards....you just joined too late :-)

redlegs

A few years ago I tried to submit cards from the 1968 Reds Picture Pack Set without success. I received a note back stating that there was not a holder available. Since that time PSA has been grading cards from the 1960's Jay's Publishing sets which are very similar in thickness and size. The Picture Pack cards measure approximately 4 & 3/4 by 7 & 1/16. I may have to give it another try. Has anyone tried recently?

firedawg45

sweet cards phil...

bobsbbcards

mikeschmidt

Unique Topps Cloth cards of young Hall of Famers are pretty darn cool, Bob!

shagrotn77

I wish they'd grade Star basketball cards like they used to.

mariotown

1982 Fleer Test
1990 Donruss Aqueous Test
1990 Donruss Blue/White Test

Anyone ever get any of these graded? I heard they grade the Aqueous now, but I don't know about the others. Didn't they also stop grading the 1995 Kraft and Quaker Granola cards?

MBMiller25

<< <i>1990 Donruss Aqueous Test >>



PSA is grading these now. Not the Blue and White's but they are grading the Red's.

1975REDS1976

I have that exact picture pack Rose card at PSA right now (was sent in late June). I will let you know if they grade it this time.

Also, in the 2009 SCD Catalogue, is the Kenwood Bench the one listed under Shillito Reds. There is a Bech listed with "Kenwood Plaza" in parentheses so that's why I was wondering. I emailed Bob Lemke a week or two ago (before I noticed the Shillito's) and he said he was aware of the Kenwood card and a Jamesway Trucking Bench I recently won. He said that if I sent scans and measurements, he would get them included in the 2011 edition. I sent him scans last week. As I said though, after I sent the email, I wondered if maybe the Bench was actually listed in their publication but under Shillito's instead of simply Kenwood Plaza.

redlegs

Hello Patrick,

Yes, please let me know if PSA grades your Picture Pack Pete Rose. Along with the Rose, I would love to get both the Johnny Bench rookie and Tony Perez graded.


I have seen an example of the Shillitos Johnny Bench only one time. It actually has the name Shillitos on it. The Sports Investments Store in Cincinnati, Ohio, has it in the museum portion of their store and is not for sale. The Shillitos Johnny Bench has the same photo of Bench that the Partridge Meats, Kenwood Plaza, and Jamesway Trucking cards that were issued in the late 1960's. There is also a Shillitos Cincinnati Reds photo set that I believe came out in 1976.

AISAVDBBALLINPHILLY

AISAVDBBALLINPHILLY

Whoops, I was logged in already. Sorry for the previous blank post. OK, I wish PSA would grade 1993 Investors Journal Cards and 1992 Cartwrights Players Choice. Anyone know if any catalogs have info on these cards. I know the 2008-09 Beckett Football does. And LT appears in both of those sets.

AISAVDBBALLINPHILLY

Got it now. Here is one of the Investor's Journal LT cards. I have a teal one and a silver prism as well.

AISAVDBBALLINPHILLY

Correction: Beckett '08-'09 Football Guide does not have the Investor's Journal or Cartwright's Players choice. If anyone has seen these in a catalog, please let me know where. I have not looked in Tuff Stuff yet, so maybe they are in there.

DavidPuddy

79 Topps Comics.

redlegs

I received a email response back from PSA regarding the 1968 Reds Picture Pack Set. They informed me that they can now grade cards from this set.