Opinions requested on a couple possible NEWP.

TennesseeDave

I am considering a couple coins for purchase and want the opinions of the forum experts.
1st is a 1875 Seated half:raw with reverse toning.


2nd is an 1877-P Trade $ Pcgs graded.



edited to correct 77-S to 77-P

doh

Personally, the half does nothing for me. It looks VERY AT.

I don't mind the look of the Trade $ though. Looks like a decent AU...providing it's not a fake in a fake slab

TomB

I absolutely hate the half dollar while the images of the dollar are truly too small to comment very much.

AUandAG

I see no mintmark on the 1877-S trade dollar.

bob

AndyMac

Was the half in some sort of holder. If it wasn't, how does one side wear that much more than the other and still retain the toning.

LotsoLuck

Oh nevermind, you wanted expert opinions.