opinion on auto

dioworld

Hi ,

I got these came with a lot i purchase, thinking of sending it in to psa for the june special for auto grading, just wanna see everyone's opinion's on these autograph to see if it's legit , is it even worth to sending it in.






thx

schr1st

The Rose looks good. Not sure on the others, but it's worth it to send them in to find out. Good luck!

onebamafan

The Rose and Mays look good.....................the other 2 i do not know enough about, if i had to bet though i would say Wilt is bogus (just a guess though).

MooseDog

Remember it doesn't matter what we think, only what someone at PSA or JSA thinks.

That being said, I don't think any of the four will pass. I'm pretty sure that the Billy and Wilt are bogus. The Mays and Rose I would lean slightly negative, but there are enough irregularities in the signatures that even if they are good there is a good chance they won't pass them and then you are out the authentication fees. When Rose was playing and chasing the Cobb record he was getting so much mail that a lot of it was secretarial, and of course since he was so popular at the time there were zillions of fakes. It's really hard to tell some of the bad Rose's from the good ones.

dioworld

Thanks guys, i think i won't submit it, just got a email back from PSA, the half price june special offers only valid for psa/dna form, not for psa form.

Nathaniel1960

What a horrible Wilt card to have auto'd. That fact alone makes me think its bogus. I think the Pete Rose looks good, but is it worth submitting? You can get a auto'd/certified bat from him delivered for under $50.

dioworld

Actually that guy bought it himself long time ago, he just throw these in with the lot. Some of them comes with a COA from i don't even know what company
if sending it in for $40 for a gamble, i might take the chance, guessing if 1 of them came back real, it might worth it. But for $80, i don't think i'll take that chance