Seeking Input From the Masses

hobart4281

Just bought a HP 5580 all in one printer/scanner and thought I'd subject the quality of the scanner to the masses by seeking opinions on the grade for this 1972 Topps #4. I would like to upgrade my 8 and I think that this card may help the cause. There is a just minor touch on the top right corner & the back is clean (centered as well as the front). Thanks in advance for any input.

Brian

Sheamaster

IMO, the top right corner will keep it from being a 9.

lsutigers1973

Rainman says 8, yeah definitely an 8.

Bunker

<< <i>IMO, the top right corner will keep it from being a 9. >>



I am afraid that I agree....maybe an 8.5?

EDITED to add that it is still a really nice looking card! How does this card compare to the 8 you have now?

WinPitcher

That ding on the top right corner may even keep it out of an 8 holder.

It is too severe. Might bring it into a 7 Holder.


Could 8, be a low end one then.

Centering and color and other corners are sweet.





Steve

hammered

I wish all auction scans were that clear

otwcards

Assuming the upper right is a corner chip and not a corner crease, the card should be a straight PSA 8. Even if it is a corner crease, it is minute enough that in most cases, it should not hinder the card ending up in a NM-MT holder.

Given the left/right centering and the corner nick, I do not see any way the card should garner a PSA 9, however.