Would PSA grade this card? HELP

MrVintage

I really need this Gehrig card for my set, but I am worried because it is in a BCCG holder. Does this card look authentic and unaltered to you guys? Any help would be apprectiated. Thanks.

WinPitcher

I doubt it is altered, it won't grade a 6 at PSA, a 2 at best.

Maybe a 3.


Steve

nam812

<< <i>I doubt it is altered, it won't grade a 6 at PSA, a 2 at best.

Maybe a 3.


Steve >>



It says "good or better", so I agree that it is reasonable to expect a 2 or maybe 3.

firedawg45

psa 2 not trimmed

MrVintage

Thanks guys....how about this one. I also need it and have never heard of this company before.

halosfan

Find a better Lou ... there is NO need to give clowns like that any of your money EVER

Referring to the second Lou

OAKESY25

yes they grade it.. psa 1

MrVintage

Its an auction on ebay.....the price tag on it is worthless

nightcrawler

Ya I'd steer away from that second one in the VCA holder. I'm guessing that grade means authentic???


The first one seems to show some creases and wrinkles so I'm going with the rest here with a PSA 2.

fkw

The R320 is a reprint so obviously dont get it graded.

The R328 is a nice card just has some registration problems, and would grade a "2"

fkw

For those that care...

On the R320... the way to tell its a reprint is (like most all reprints) the borders have been cropped when they designed the reprint (They need to crop the borders and add new pure white borders so they wouldnt have print dots in the white border when they rescreen the card).

On R320's reprint/authentic ID
Look at the distance between the name and the border, button on hat and border, and also the small silhouette players and the copyright logo too. The colors are off too but its harder to explain ( I see it right away)..... Usually the darks are too dark compared to the lights (often on Ruth fakes he looks like a raccoon)

authentic R320 #61 (google image)