QUICK opinions.. fantasy trade

OAKESY25

mike lowell
c.c
verlander

for

arod
corey hart
roy oswalt..

which trio would you rather have???
12 team head to head league

Barndog

Lowell et al. CC and Verlander are just getting good. When Youkilis comes back, Lowell will have even more RBI (and GIDP ) opportunities

joestalin

Sorry to highjack this thread but what about this trade:

Santana
Reyes
Beltran
Sheff
Pelfrey

for

Matt Stairs?

I think its close

gumbyfan

<< <i>Sorry to highjack this thread but what about this trade:

Santana
Reyes
Beltran
Sheff
Pelfrey

for

Matt Stairs?

I think its close >>



How about the Sillies' starting rotation

for

1/2lb of peanut shells?

flash300

Giving up way to many peanut shells

perkdog

<< <i>mike lowell
c.c
verlander

for

arod
corey hart
roy oswalt..

which trio would you rather have???
12 team head to head league >>



C.C, Verlander & Lowell!

Cubby

I supose(sp?) it really depends on what you need, but the advantage
stats wise goes to Lowell, CC, Verlander.

TheVon

Trades can be so hard to decide on. I think it depends on how you want to look at it.

What I mean is, if you go player for player I'd rather have the 2nd group. Here's why:
I'd take-
A-Rod over Lowell
CC over Hart
Oswalt over Verlander
So that's 2-1 for the second group.

On the other hand, if you mix up the comparisons I'd take:
A-Rod over Lowell
CC over Oswalt
Verlander over Hart
So that's 2-1 for the first group.

And then you have to factor in your league's scoring system, your needs, your competitor's strengths and weaknesses . . .

Jackrabbit

I'd take the 2nd group..