What to do with these N1, N6, and N8's from PSA...

MULLINS5

I have a few cards that have come back, and some that are on their way back, from PSA that were not graded because I requested not to have the qualifier. They are a range from N1 to N8 and I am wondering what would be the best thing to do with them. Should I attempt to even try to sell these off (of course stating in the auction clearly the PSA question, and providing the labels to the purchaser) or should I just toss them? The miscut cards have PSA labels and certification number, but are not slabbed. The only thing that really scares me about selling these is the potential of the purchaser using them to scam somebody else. Thanks in advance. Patrick


The cards so far are:

1979 OPC Mike Bossy #230 N8:MISCUT
1979 Topps Mike Bossy #230 N6: MINIMUM SIZE REQUIREMENT
1979 OPC League Leaders #7 N8: MISCUT
1980 Topps Ray Bourque #140 N1: EVIDENCE OF TRIMMING
1980 OPC Stanley Cup Semi-Finals #262 N8: MISCUT

NickM

They weren't not graded because you didn't request the qualifier. These were rejected with or without qualifiers.
N8 miscuts weren't graded because the card's not a rectangle.
N6 minimum size requirements weren't graded because the card is smaller than it should be, but there are no signs of trimming on it.
N1 evidence of trimmings weren't graded because something about the card evidences that it was altered by trimming.

There's no reason to toss any of the cards. If you're selling them, you should definitely disclose the PSA rejection.
With respect to the N1 card, if you're really confident that it has not been trimmed, consider resubmitting it. PSA does make errors.

Nick

Statman

If you wanted to get them slabbed, you could try sending to SGC also. Grading is an opinion, and maybe there's would be different. I've had cards rejected by PSA before that SGC slabbed. Or even try sending them in again to PSA. There are countless stories on here about people did that and the second time they go through and get graded. But I wouldn't toss them out. if nothing else, I think you could sell them, disclosing the issues with PSA.

alifaxwa2

I would say submit them again. Odds are a couple maybe slabbed the second time around.

lsutigers1973

N8 miscut you will not get into a PSA holder. N1 you can if it truly isn't trimmed. N6 you can get into a holder. Just compare it to another card from the same set. If it is slightly larger than it is supposed to be it will keep getting an N6.

KbKards

Why not start an N set? You're almost a third of the way complete.

WinPitcher

I'd recheck them, if the MC appear ok I'd resub them.

Same with the other 2.

Steve

WinPitcher

Bill

I have gotten N8's graded the second time around.

It all depends on the card.


I have yet not gotten a card holdered that was at first rejected.

Of course I'm talking about cards that I know for a fact were not trimmed and the MC's were not in my opinion MC.

I have never had a N6 (size requirement) returned.

I will be sending a presentation set card of Drysdale so we will see.


Steve

lsutigers1973

I have resubbed quite a few N8's and have yet to get one in a holder. Also never had an EOT that didn't eventually make it's way into a holder.