Grade the Proof Barber Quarter! Grade Revealed!

AnkurJ

Two sets of pics, both by Mark Goodman. One that shows the toning, the other showing the proof surfaces.

Graded MS62.



AJ

commoncents05

PR63.

-Paul

doh

64, nice colors

STONE

IMO those hairlines in the fields hurt, and I'll go 63.

KlectorKid

PR62

coinkid855

PR 62



-Paul

CarlWohlforth

I call it a very nice looking 63, very nice. Light cameo contrast, toning, just enough hairlines to make it affordable, not enough to bother me, yup, if I guessed right it is my kind of coin!

Rob85635

What a beaut! Are the hairlines in the pics showing toning on the coin or are they the result of something else? The first set of pictures I would guess PR62, the second set PR66. Big difference to me. Am I way off?

Bayard1908

Unless the slab is really scratched, 61

relicsncoins

I'll go 62. I think there are just too many hairlines to get into a 63 holder.

bushmaster8

You're joking right? How can anyone possibly grade a proof from pics? Even Mark's pics!

AnkurJ

It is indeed graded an NGC PF62.

Ankur

KlectorKid

<< <i>You're joking right? How can anyone possibly grade a proof from pics? Even Mark's pics! >>



I agree with you. It's impossible to grade a proof from pictures, the only thing you can do is grade the picture and assume the photographer is being straight forward. Those are some extremely honest pictures.