Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

Been here 2 years & Mineral Oil & IHC's...

Okay all, I joined here 2 years ago... saw my first Indian Head cents & liked them alot. As a coin "Newbie" I bought a bunch of IHC rolls on eBay... LOL... OMG what a frickin' waste of money that was. image These were overall culls, crappy, cruddy, worn, dirty, corroded, green & questionable - with a *few* okay'ish specimens.

So, after seeing may threads as to the pros & cons of Olive Oil soaking, I decided to try Mineral Oil instead (it doesn't go rancid) - I took some of the best & the worst coins (about 60 of 'em, plus a couple Lincolns)... well, checked every few weeks/months at first & saw no difference... so decided to put them "away".

Have pretty much just returned to the forum this last week after a 8+ month hiatus.... ah hah ~ lemme go find those IHC's, they've been soaking nearly TWO YEARS!!!! Well, guess what?! They look JUST THE SAME as when I dropped them in the oil!!!!!! Except - now they are all shiney w/ oil!! ARGH ~ Half a bottle of dish detergent did nada...

So, my guess is that Olive Oil must have some natural substance that actually reacts with crud & discoloration... but mineral oil does not. The oil was still perfectly clear (except for a random speck of dirt)... I even tried a coarse brush on some of the unsavable ones just to check, nope- nothing budging.

So, if anyone else is considering Mineral Oil - Just Say NO - I'm thinking stick with extra virgin olive oil & change it regularly!! Just my "60" cents ~ image

Comments

  • Options
    smokincoinsmokincoin Posts: 2,636 ✭✭✭
    Thanks for sharing! image
  • Options
    Too say I was abit dissappointed is a HUGE understatement!! After they were in the oil about 2 months I had wished I had photographed the whole collection for B4 & Afta pics.... guess I'm glad I didn't now!! I was utterly astounded by the lack of any change at all ~ ah well, guess I'll invest in some high quality olive oil (if I can get past cooking w/ it though...LOL).
  • Options
    element159element159 Posts: 601 ✭✭✭
    I would be interested to see a comparison of mineral oil vs olive oil, with similar coins soaked for the same time in each. Not a quick experiment, though!

    There is a significant chemical difference between the two - olive oil contains oxygen (it is an ester), as well as carbon double bonds. Mineral oil is a straight hydrocarbon, like gasoline.
  • Options
    kevinstangkevinstang Posts: 1,521 ✭✭✭


    << <i>Too say I was abit dissappointed is a HUGE understatement!! After they were in the oil about 2 months I had wished I had photographed the whole collection for B4 & Afta pics.... guess I'm glad I didn't now!! I was utterly astounded by the lack of any change at all ~ ah well, guess I'll invest in some high quality olive oil (if I can get past cooking w/ it though...LOL). >>



    If you want to speed the process up, heat the olive oil, soak coins quickly in it then submerge in ice water- literally cooks the crud off in minutes instead of weeks- I use if for the copper coins I find metal detecting.
  • Options
    BroadstruckBroadstruck Posts: 30,497 ✭✭✭✭✭


    << <i>

    << <i>Too say I was abit dissappointed is a HUGE understatement!! After they were in the oil about 2 months I had wished I had photographed the whole collection for B4 & Afta pics.... guess I'm glad I didn't now!! I was utterly astounded by the lack of any change at all ~ ah well, guess I'll invest in some high quality olive oil (if I can get past cooking w/ it though...LOL). >>



    If you want to speed the process up, heat the olive oil, soak coins quickly in it then submerge in ice water- literally cooks the crud off in minutes instead of weeks- I use if for the copper coins I find metal detecting. >>



    Might as well add some freshly pressed garlic while your at it image
    To Err Is Human.... To Collect Err's Is Just Too Much Darn Tootin Fun!

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file