GONG (grade or no grade) an 1910 S Lincoln

DwaineO

Same coin just different positions in relationship with the lights and camera.

LikesLincoln

MS64RB

MPLunatic

i say will grade, and 63 due to a few flecks and rb maybe brown, hard to tell from pic

lkenefic

Tough one... I'd say a definite maybe!

Seriously though... the first pic looks OK. The second makes me question the color. I have a 1929-D that wasn't dipped but I've been told it has been chemically treated to give "mint luster" (HCN I think??)

If the color is real, I'd say easily 63... probably 64.

ChrisRx

63rb

fc

looks fine to me and i see no reason why it would not grade.

drwstr123

No more than 63RB. Nice.

TwoSides2aCoin

<< <i>looks fine to me and i see no reason why it would not grade. >>



Risk vs. Reward


No brainer, but the reverse skeers me a wee bit if one is seeking a GRADE.
I ain't sayin' it won't and I ain't sayin' it will. I'm just holding up the scale.

LikesLincoln

<< <i>looks fine to me and i see no reason why it would not grade. >>



Come on, its way better than Fine. Definately MS!

robkool

MS63RB...

DwaineO

14168614 2440 1910-S 1C US Genuine (91 - Questionable Color)

TwoSides2aCoin

<< <i>14168614 2440 1910-S 1C US Genuine (91 - Questionable Color) >>



Thank you for sharing.

DwaineO

Your welcome. I think I am going to hold onto it and submit it again with another lot in the future.

TwoSides2aCoin

DwaineO, my first post and the results of your test have confirmed why I was only holding a scale.
I was basing my doubts off of a picture on a coin with a great strike, obviously authentic looking, but something didn't look right to me. If these guys had it "in hand" and it only gets a genuine, maybe if you want a net grade you should try ANACS. Someone here might know how that process works, but I'm not sure 're-submitting' even a dozen times will change the results at PCGS. Seriously and respectfully,


Joe