Grade 2 lowball commems; guess the grade on SLH lowball

InYHWHWeTrust

Posting these for a good friend, pocketpiececommems. Bob will moderate this thread and PM him for any questions. Thanks in advance for your opinions.

Columbian 1:





Columbian 2:





SLH in PCGS plastic. There is an ebaY link for a comparision coin, that Bob or I'll have to edit in later after you guess the grade.

STONE

2
1
1

NumisOxide

AG-03
FA-02
AG-03

rbf

Colombian #1 = Fair-2
Colombian #2 = Poor-1
Seated Liberty = Fair-2

Colorfulcoins

Col #1: AG3 (3 obv, 2 rev)
Col #2: authenic, no grade, can't determine date
Seated: Fr2 (1 obv, 2 rev)

InYHWHWeTrust

Both Columbians came back NO GRADE, though I think the first is 1893 Po-1 and the second I would agree with

Here is PCGS opinion of the the SLH:



And a recently ended auction for comparison of CGS consistency:

PCGS SLH Fair 2 ???