Matte Proof Lincoln's for the week of 1-14

WaterSport · January 13, 2009 10:48AM

Not much of any change from last week. Just a couple new additions keeping us at 44 total.

Till next week

WS

1909VDB
N/A

1909
1909 PCGS PR 65 RED Ebay

1909 ICG PR 60 cleaned Heritage

1909 PCGS PR 66 RED Heritage

1909 PCGS PR 67 RED Heritage

1909 PCGS 66 RED $8000 Angel Dees
No Picture

1909 PCGS 65 R&B $3250 Angel Dees
No Picture

1910

1910 PCGS 64R&B $1150 DR.Gene Bruder

1910 NGC PR 64 R&B Ebay

1910 PCGS PR 64 BRN CAC Ebay $1795

1910 PCGS PR 66 RED Heritage

1910 PCGS 64 R&B $1450 Angel Dees
No Picture

1911

1911 NGC PR 65 BRN Collectors Corner $1900
No Picture

1911 PCGS PR 64 BRN Teletrade

1911 PCGS PR 65 R&B Heritage

1911 PCGS PR 66 RED Heritage

1911 PCGS PR 65 RED Heritage

1911 PCGS PR 65 R&B $2500 Angel Dees
No Picture

1911 PCGS PR 64 R&B $1700 Angel Dees
No Picture

1911 PCGS PR 65 BRN $2200 Angel Dees
No Picture

1912

1912 PCGS PR 63 R&B Ebay

1912 PCGS PR 64 R&B $2098.75 OBO Heritage

1912 PCGS 64 BRN Charmy Harker

1912 PCGS PR 65 BRN PQ $4000 Angel Dees
No Picture

1912 PCGS PR 65 BRN $2950 Angel Dees
No Picture

1912 PCGS PR 65 BRN $1950 Brian Wagner

1912 PCGS PR 64 BRN $1250 Brian Wagner

1912 NGC PR 64 R&B $2000 JJ Teaparty

1912 NGC 66 BRN BIN $4950 Ebay

1913

1913 NGC PR 65 RED Collectors Corner $2250

1913 PCGS PR 65 R&B Ebay

1913 PCGS PR 65 R&B $2750 Ebay

1913 PCGS 64R&B $1000 DR.Gene Bruder

1913 NGC PR 64 R&B $805 Heritage

1913 NGC PR 65 RED $ 2012.50 CAC Heritage

1913 PCGS PR 65 RED $3750 Angel Dees
No Picture

1913 ANACS PR 64 R&B $1279 J.J. Teaparty

1913 PCGS PR 64 BRN Charmy Harker

1913 PCGS PR 65 R&B Charmy Harker

1913 PCGS PR 66 R&B $4100 Angel Dees
No Picture

1913 NGC PR 67 RED $8,500 Northeast Numismatics

1913 PCGS PR 65 R&B $2500 Brian Wagner

1914

1914 NGC PR 66 R&B Collectors Corner

1914 NGC PR 66 BRN (cent is part of a complete NGC 1914 Proof Set)Heritage

1914 PCGS PR 65 RED OGH Heritage

1914 PCGS PR 63 R&B $1850 Charmy Harker

1915
N/A

1916

1916 NGC PR 67 R&B BIN $19,500 Ebay

illini420 · January 13, 2009 11:21AM

Thanks for the post

If anyone wants the deal of the year... 1909 VDB Proof on eBay right now... couple of hours left, I've already been outbid

eBay Link

From the seller upon request for better pics & pics of the rims & edges:

<< I currently do not have a scanner and my camera gets blury the more I zoom in. Sorry about that. As far as authenticating as a proof, I've been selling coins from my Grandfather's collection that was left to me. All coins that I've been selling come from his itemized collection that he also kept a book on himself. He was a serious collector. Check my feedback from buyers all have been satisfied and I have had no problems thus far. I also did a little research myself and from what I've found it is a proof. Thank You for your interest! >>

Steve · January 13, 2009 12:30PM

<< 

If anyone wants the deal of the year... 1909 VDB Proof on eBay right now... couple of hours left >>

Michael, seriously, you MUST know this isn't a REAL 1909 VDB Matte Proof Lincoln cent, right? And would you pay even $10 for a raw VF MS version? Of course not. It seems you, like many other Lincoln cent collectors have a dream. Maybe, just maybe you'll hit the lottery called the real 09VDB MPL. Well good luck. The best chance anyone had of getting the real thing at a so called "reasonable" price occurred last week at FUN.
Steve

RBinTex · January 13, 2009 12:46PM

Great job (again) Bob. Makes it a bit easier carrying over those already linked/imaged, etc. and only linking new ones.

illini420 · January 13, 2009 3:41PM

<< 

<< 

If anyone wants the deal of the year... 1909 VDB Proof on eBay right now... couple of hours left >>

Michael, seriously, you MUST know this isn't a REAL 1909 VDB Matte Proof Lincoln cent, right? And would you pay even $10 for a raw VF MS version? Of course not. It seems you, like many other Lincoln cent collectors have a dream. Maybe, just maybe you'll hit the lottery called the real 09VDB MPL. Well good luck. The best chance anyone had of getting the real thing at a so called "reasonable" price occurred last week at FUN.
Steve

>>

Steve, of course I know the chances of it being THE coin, is extremely slim. However, with poor photos, you never know...

The coin looks better than VF from what I can see, so I thought it would be worth it to place a small bid on it, small enough to where I'd be happy with coin if I won it and was able to confirm it's not a proof for sure

I guess someone else wanted it more. Someday someone will get very lucky... I'm just not going to be the one spending crazy money gambling.

RBinTex · January 13, 2009 10:42PM

How cool if it came back in a PCGS genuine holder. A nice tidy 10000% gain?

BWRC · January 14, 2009 12:03AM

New from BWRC $2,950

"OGH" 1916 $11,250

ChrisRx · January 14, 2009 6:39AM

<< New from BWRC $2,950

"OGH" 1916 $11,250

>>

RBinTex · January 14, 2009 7:40AM

Hi Guys,

It seems like it would be fairer to all sellers AND more efficient (from both a bandwith and a duplication minimization perspective) if sellers forwarded Bob via PM the code with the link/images, etc. that they want him to insert into the main/title post.

Certainly a note could be added such as "*added 1/15/09" (e.g.)

Just my thoughts & HO.

illini420 · January 14, 2009 10:25AM

<< New from BWRC $2,950

>>

Awesome looking 1911

dbemike · January 14, 2009 7:31PM

Newly listed on Ebay in auction format starting at 99c

PCGS 1913 PR65RB OGH

PCGS 1909 PR65RD

Steve · January 14, 2009 8:52PM

IMHO fairtraderz is a fool for listing these coins at 99 cents. All it does is imply the coin can be gotten cheap and will bring out all the dreamers out there. Steve

RBinTex · January 14, 2009 9:50PM

Personally I congratulate them for listing it at .99 w/ no reserve.

WaterSport · January 14, 2009 9:59PM

I am betting they will do better than at Heritage..

WS

dbemike · January 15, 2009 4:28AM

A collector won't be able to steal them at a low price for a collection, theres to many flippers out there to let these go to lower than they normally would on Ebay a few years ago. JMO...

It sure a long list going here...you were lucky to see this many listed in a year in 2002-2004

WaterSport · January 15, 2009 6:13AM

Here is another 1911 NGC 65 BRN $1900
WS
Text1911 MPL at Collectors Corner

Another 1913 NGC 65 RED $2250

Text1913 Collectors Corner

Another 1914 NGC 66 R&B $2850

Text1914 Collectors Corner

dbemike · January 15, 2009 8:00PM

Another on Ebay

PCGS 1912 PR63RB

curly · January 15, 2009 11:59PM

Brothers, MPLs seem to be coming out of the woodwork lately. Some look pretty nice and a few others you could hear barkin' across the bourse floor. Now might be a good time to do a little cherrypickin'.

RBinTex · January 16, 2009 5:45AM

Sweet little '12 there for $1,250

ambro51 · January 16, 2009 5:54AM

sure looks "undergraded'' to me.

Most 12's have tons of color..but if da home team says its original....then its original.

Ive noted that the 16's are still "in the woodwork". aside from that high grade one angledees had/has how many others have there been over the last year?

ChrisRx · January 16, 2009 6:44AM

<< sure looks "undergraded'' to me. >>

I'm gonna have to disagree. I think its a 63 all day.

Steve · January 16, 2009 7:03AM

<< IMHO fairtraderz is a fool for listing these coins at 99 cents. All it does is imply the coin can be gotten cheap and will bring out all the dreamers out there. Steve

>>

OK, I see that NOW on EBAY these certified MPL's DO get bid up to their anticipated values. Think we will ever see a PCGS slabbed 1909VDB MPL listed on EBAY? with no reserve? It WOULD be interesting to see how it was bid during a 10 day run. I'd bet it just won't happen.
Steve

Duane · January 16, 2009 10:49AM

Bob-

Great job with the posted photos and links. I agree with Curly. Many MPLs to choose from; but important to pick the right ones.

I like the 1909s that are starting to appear, but the '15s and 16s are seem in hiding, for the most part. I still think the 1916 is the most under-valued in the series.

Eye appeal + scarcity = big $$

Duane

WaterSport · January 17, 2009 1:42AM

Duane, you raised a good question that got me to wonder how many 1916 MPL have com to market so I went back and looked at all the MPL list since its conception in september of 2007. Now consider the fact that these coins are bought and sold and I have no way of knowing which ones were the "same" coin listed more than once (twice?) over this time frame. But amazingly 23 have been listed just this past year, with a total of 31 since the list began.

WS

Steve · January 17, 2009 4:17AM

<< Duane, you raised a good question that got me to wonder how many 1916 MPL have com to market so I went back and looked at all the MPL list since its conception in september of 2007. Now consider the fact that these coins are bought and sold and I have no way of knowing which ones were the "same" coin listed more than once (twice?) over this time frame. But amazingly 23 have been listed just this past year, with a total of 31 since the list began.

WS >>

Bob,
If it isn't too difficult with your database, could you tell us how many 1909VDB MPL's have been listed in the past year and in total since the list began? If it is rather easy, I'm sure we'd all also like to know how each of the nine MPL varieties stack up for the last year and in total since the listing began. Please, don't make a project out of it, but it would be interesting to know all these numbers. Thanks,
Steve

dbemike · January 17, 2009 7:47AM

Everywhere I look I happen to stumble across a new one.

PCGS 1911 PR65BN $1150

illini420 · January 17, 2009 8:33AM

<< Everywhere I look I happen to stumble across a new one.

PCGS 1911 PR65BN $1150 >>

These things are popping up all over suddenly... this one here is significantly under the PCGS guide prices too. Will we see some red in the Price Guide soon??? Is the party over???

RBinTex · January 17, 2009 8:47AM

Pretty fugly for a 65.

lusterlover · January 17, 2009 9:44AM

<< 

<< Everywhere I look I happen to stumble across a new one.

PCGS 1911 PR65BN $1150 >>

These things are popping up all over suddenly... this one here is significantly under the PCGS guide prices too. Will we see some red in the Price Guide soon??? Is the party over??? >>

The price guide is for solid examples. PQ coins will trade higher, and fugly coins will trade lower. The party is not over. Take a look at the picture; there's a reason for the discount. I'd even go as far to say there might be a fingerprint on the lower obverse.

BWRC · January 18, 2009 12:00AM

<< 

<< Everywhere I look I happen to stumble across a new one.

PCGS 1911 PR65BN $1150 >>

These things are popping up all over suddenly... this one here is significantly under the PCGS guide prices too. Will we see some red in the Price Guide soon??? Is the party over??? >>

RE: 1911 PCGS PR65BN

"Most likely a quality issue as the next lot and same date in the same auction graded NGC PR65BN sold for $1,668"?

renomedphys · January 18, 2009 6:52AM

<< Pretty fugly for a 65. >>

Matte Proof Lincoln's for the week of 1-14

Comments