Regrade a 1975 psa 8.5 aaron hilight or not?

trapperlad

I just got my psa poppage on a 1975 topps aaron highlights card #1 and it popped at a 8.5. should I regrade and go for a 9 or leave at the only 8.5 ever graded. What does someone think it is worth at this grade when it is the only 8.5 graded. I also popped some 1957 topps football in PSA 8. #90 lansford, #97 Dibble, 2 @ #100 childress, 101 Nickel #98 Scudero and a PSA 7 140 bratkowski

VitoCo1972

Are you selling/trading those 57 football?

ldferg

trapperlad,
here's my latest experience: i had an aaron hl graded an 8. sent it in and it came back a 6. i am sending it in one last time. fingers crossed to get it back to the 8.

good luck whatever you decide.

trapperlad

I would be willing to trade on of the Childess for another PSA 8 low pop High #. But I'm still wondering what a person thinks the 1975 topps psa 8 .5 aaron Card #1 would go for.

Bosox1976

I'd try to sell it once with a B-I-N of $225 to $250. If it sells - great, if not - crack & resubmit.

MBMiller25

Ide keep the card in the PSA 8.5 slab. I was thinking LD Ferg though when I saw the title of this post. David is going to have his work cut out for him getting that PSA 8 back.