SGC to PSA crossover question...

freddyp23

Just bought this today from ebay and was wondering if to leave it in its current holder or to cross it over to PSA...All my graded cards are PSA and that is the only reason Id want to do it but im afraid it would get a lower grade from PSA...Thanks in advance for your thoughs and opinions
1957 Mantle

stevek

<< <i>Just bought this today from ebay and was wondering if to leave it in its current holder or to cross it over to PSA...All my graded cards are PSA and that is the only reason Id want to do it but im afraid it would get a lower grade from PSA...Thanks in advance for your thoughs and opinions
1957 Mantle >>




Nice card - I would say you've got a decent shot at a PSA 5. Can't see it going lower than a PSA 4 - Worth a try in my opinion.

dtkk49a

Submit it in the holder. As long as they don't BB you for trimming, I think it will cross as a 4.

PoppaJ

Very nice looking card with excellent centering!

IMO, I would crack and submit rather than cross-over.

We've tried both ways when sending in SGC to PSA and
crack & subs always came back the same or higher, never lower, while
cross-overs sporatically come back lower.

I agree with SteveK that your card is a strong 4, possible 4.5 or 5.

Eye appeal means a lot, and your card certainly has that going for it.

Good luck no matter which way you go!

PoppaJ