What would you grade my lil Pilgrim?

chaze215

I purchased it raw and like it much better in hand vs. seller's pix. Looking for one more to finish that section of my 7070. Thanks in advance.

Jcarney

AU50

SDSportsFan

I'd rather not have anything to do with your "lil Pilgrim"

The coin on the other hand, I'd say no better than AU50, due to the lack of luster.

Still a nice coin


Steve

lasvegasteddy

xf45 sweet looking pilgrim too

jmj3esq

XF40

bidask

50

GoldenEyeNumismatics

au50

fcloud

50

mozin

Sorry, but your Pilgrim is not much to talk about. Nice that you like it, but perhaps you should consider buying only encapsulated Classic Commems until you learn more about grading them.

Barberian

With Circulated commems, the grade rarely has much effect on the price. It's the look that is much more important.

There is no need to learn how to grade Classic commems. They're pretty darn difficult to grade anyway.

julie43

AU58

Steve27

AU55

chaze215

<< <i>Sorry, but your Pilgrim is not much to talk about. Nice that you like it, but perhaps you should consider buying only encapsulated Classic Commems until you learn more about grading them. >>



mozin: I dont need any snide comments directed my way with regards to grading Classic Commems. I simply asked for a possible grade, so perhaps you should stick to the original question and not offer any additional useless information.

Thanks to everyone else giving their input on a possible grade.

messydesk

40

291fifth

XF45

derryb

<< <i>Sorry, but your Pilgrim is not much to talk about. Nice that you like it, but perhaps you should consider buying only encapsulated Classic Commems until you learn more about grading them. >>



Maybe the original poster is collecting a set in the grade of this coin. I didn't see anything in the original post where he thought is was a high grade coin. Maybe his grading skills don't need to be questioned. All he asked for was a grading opinion of others.

DRUNNER

Nice circulation-cameo look and appears superbly original. 45 would be my guess. I think it is interesting to think where this might have been for a while . . . to get that degree of circulation it may have been a pocket piece? It certainly didn't 'circulate' that much, but perhaps I have no imagination!

Nice piece . . . all there and a fun hunk of history.

Drunner

lcoopie

does it have any luster left?

PS His face looks like your icon

harvey85422458

first impression solid great looking xf 45

Cam40

some areas look worked-on as in, altered surfaces but
its no telling from a pic or scan. either way it looks well handled
so,maybe net 40 cleaned?

pocketpiececommems

XF40 Nice gray color

sumdunce

XF45

chaze215

<< <i>does it have any luster left?

PS His face looks like your icon >>



You're right. Although my icon is a bit more creepy.
Thanks everyone's input.

pheh

Small and unimpressive? Oh, the coin... XF.

MikeInFL

Great looking coin, I'd pay 45 or 50 money for, but I would only grade 40 (lack of luster).