Guess the Grade of a 1936 Buffalo Bison 5 Cent

Broadstruck

First off this is raw and going to be sent in to the slab factory soon, no issues or marks anywhere except one line in the indians hair.

Hyperion

fake. please send to be for proper disposal.

TennesseeDave

64 and where do you find all of those broadstruck coins?

TwoSides2aCoin

MS 64 if they don't gig it for the scratch on the side of Chief's head.

OffMetal

I initially thought 65, but I didn't see that scratch-thing...

Nice coin! You certainly know how to make me drool!

Broadstruck

<< <i>64 and where do you find all of those broadstruck coins? >>



This was located in the back of the safe of a B&M in a old manila envelope that stated "Unc 1936 Freak" by an ole typewritter.

GoldenEyeNumismatics

64

pheh

Grade: Freak'in Great!

I dunno, I guess I'd be surprised if it didn't 65 as an off-center. PCGS BB/65 - NGC 65.

STONE

64, maybe 65.

Or you can keep it raw and sell it to me first.

SUMORADA

Wow........tough crowd......65-66.......nice coin.......

robkool

MS65...

GrumpyEd

<< <i>64, maybe 65. >>



Sweeeeeeeet!

yellowjacket

PCGS is unbelievably harsh when grading "freaks." I like the coin.

63

Garrow

Type2

I dont care it's coollll. It will go MS65

Broadstruck

Thanks everyone!

Shamika

Gorgeous coin that I'd love to have. MS65

zeebob

Unless I miss something, MS-66. I see the mark in the hair and a tiny contact mark by the Y. Other than that it's a clean coin. I don't get why others are tossing around MS-63, MS-64 and MS-65 grades.

Seems nicely struck and the hair hides marks nicely. Fields are clean.

Keep us posted. I'll be interested to hear your slab grade.

Good luck,

Bob

Broadstruck

<< <i>Unless I miss something, MS-66. I see the mark in the hair and a tiny contact mark by the Y. Other than that it's a clean coin. I don't get why others are tossing around MS-63, MS-64 and MS-65 grades.

Seems nicely struck and the hair hides marks nicely. Fields are clean.

Keep us posted. I'll be interested to hear your slab grade.

Good luck,

Bob >>



The contact mark at Y in Liberty is on the blank flan or unstruck planchet doesn't affect the grade on an error as you only grading the actual struck area on a error.

zeebob

So what are you thinking the grade will be?

Broadstruck

<< <i>So what are you thinking the grade will be? >>



Either this or that... we shall see!