Guess the ICG Grade - 1809 CBH - results posted

JZrarities

1809 Capped Bust Half - Normal Edge

A) Guess the ICG Grade
Post your opinion of the actual grade

Any Overton help would be appreciated...

SilverEagles92

a) VF20, Artificial Toning
b) VF20, Artificial Toning

Smittys

VF20
F15

Tvac897

VF 19

FishyOne

Obverse - VF35

Reverse - VF25

Net of VF30

zap1111

Hard to tell variety from these images but I would venture a guess as O. 106, R. 3, based on T-I relationship, star position and what appears to be a recut base on the N in UNITED. Also looks like a cleaned coined that has retoned - I don't know if I'd go so far as to say AT.
A. VF25
B. VF20

JZrarities

It definitely looked a little undergraded to me, and judging by the above guesses, most of you think so too.
Graded in the early days of ICG (small serial number on front)
I just put it on the BST for $150

nicetoning42107

In a way it doesn't surprise me since ICG is conservative on some of these circulated classics. BUT it could be net graded. Toning looks natural but I think I see some rim dings on the reverse and also some cuts on the neck on the obverse.

coinpictures

Actually, looks right on the money to me...