Who should win?

FavreFan1971

I could care less about the PSA award but who should be #1 in a set if lets say you have at set 100% completed and a set rating of 9.0 but another guy has only 90% of the set but a rating higher than mine?

Why should someone who has not completed the set be #1 and not the guy (or gal) who completed the set be #1?

Just curious what others think.

perkdog

Thats where the grade weight comes in, I have no problem with a guy who has the "tougher" cards in a higher grade win.

nike24801

Seems a no-brainer to me that a guy with 90% of the set in let's say 8s & 9s should win over a guy with 100% of the set in 5s & 6s. While this is probably not your situation, it illustrates the point.

Jasen

JasP24

<< <i>Seems a no-brainer to me that a guy with 90% of the set in let's say 8s & 9s should win over a guy with 100% of the set in 5s & 6s.

Jasen >>





That's the whole purpose of the grade weights...

Jason