Possible Submission Material--What Do You Think?--GRADES IN

TonyC

I am thinking about sending some of these cards in for my free membership grades. What do you think of them?

bobbybakeriv

Nice cards. I really like that Yount RC.

brianwintersfan

Well it depends what you plan on doing with them. If you want to sell them I would probably keep looking as they all have some corner/centering issues. If you plan on keeping them go right ahead. Many guys slab stuff that have sentimental value if nothing else.

brianwintersfan

<< <i>Nice cards. I really like that Yount RC. >>



The Yount looks nice from the front but the cut on the back leaves something to be desired.

TonyC

I am kind of just looking for grade estimates.

brianwintersfan

<< <i>I am kind of just looking for grade estimates. >>



Well like I said if you plan on keeping them for sentimental reasons does it really matter if it's a 5 or a 6??

bobbybakeriv

I think that the Yount is an 8.5 - 9 candidate.

Bosox1976

Tony:

Here's my guesses based on the nice scans -

Doubleheader Ted - ??
Namath - 6
Yaz RC - 6
Bench RC - 6
55 Ted - 6
Yount - 8
Kaline - 8
Spahn - 8
Howe - 7.5
OPC Mario - 8
Topps Mario - 8.5

All very nice and all worthy of grading - but the doubleheader may require a separate submission and may not be worth the $$ therefore.

Leiascards

<< <i>Tony:

Here's my guesses based on the nice scans -

Doubleheader Ted - ??
Namath - 6
Yaz RC - 6
Bench RC - 6
55 Ted - 6
Yount - 8
Kaline - 8
Spahn - 8
Howe - 7.5
OPC Mario - 8
Topps Mario - 8.5

All very nice and all worthy of grading - but the doubleheader may require a separate submission and may not be worth the $$ therefore. >>



Based on what I can tell from the scans I think you are pretty close

otwcards

The Yount is only going up in value...

fattymacs

Too many Barley pops at the course today to give grades, very nice cards and you should be happy when they come back.

My guess is the 68 Kaline is the top of the class.

otwcards

The Double Header is probably a PSA 4, but I've seen worse in PSA 5.

The only card that may have a back centering issue is the 1960 Yaz... The others should not be hurt by the back centering.

OAKESY25

WILLIAMS - 6 MC
NAMATH - 7.5
YAZ - 7
BENCH - 7
WILLIAMS 7 MAYBE 6 DUE TO THE TILT
YOUNT 9 OR TRIMMED ( I DONT THINK IT IS )
KALINE 8.5-9
SPAHN - 7
HOWE 8
MARIO OPC - 8
MARIO - 9

Ahmanfan

those are some beauts! If I were sending my 6 freebies, I would send:
66 Namath
55 Williams
68 Bench
75 Yount
Howe
whichever mario is nicer.

some people might not think they should be graded, but everyone will agree these are nice cards.
John

WinPitcher

Nice cards, I'd grade them all.


Steve

TonyC

Mailed out the Yount, Sphan, Yaz, Namath and 2 Ryan Rookies. I will post went I get them back.
Thanks Mike

mickeymantle24

Good Luck with the grading, all of the cards look nice

TonyC

Order #20214450 / Submission #4622321
Line # Item # Cert # Grade Description Type Country
1 1 15441523 NEAR MINT-MINT 8 1975 TOPPS 223 ROBIN YOUNT Card US
2 1 15441524 EXCELLENT-MINT 6 1966 TOPPS 96 JOE NAMATH Card US
3 1 15441525 EXCELLENT-MINT 6 1960 TOPPS 148 CARL YASTRZEMSKI ROOKIE STAR Card US
4 1 15441526 MINT 9 1951 TOPPS RED BACK 30 WARREN SPAHN Card US
5 1 15441527 NEAR MINT-MINT 8 1968 TOPPS 177 METS ROOKIES J.KOOSMAN/N.RYAN Card US
6 1 15441528 NEAR MINT 7 1968 TOPPS 177 METS ROOKIES J.KOOSMAN/N.RYAN Card US


I'm very pleased. The two Ryans are mine from when I was a kid. My membership ran out this week and I didn't re up yet; could someone give me the pop report on the 1951 Spahn?

RonBurgundy

Pop report on '51 Spahn is 47. Nice grades!

Depending on the upper left corner on the Yount, that card may be undergraded.


RB

Bosox1976

grote15

8 is accurate on the Yount, IMO, though you may eventually get the .5 bump on that one. I have also found that PSA will grade star cards rougher than commons for the most part.