Would you crack these out?

mmync

Should I crack these out?

This Henderson was graded years ago. It's definitely nicer than the two 8's underneath it, and probably just as nice as a 9 I got recently. I wouldn't think it would come back as a 7.








I can't imagine A-rod dropping to a 6.5 or 6





About the only thing that could make Clemens cards worth any less is being in BCCG holders.

OAKESY25

crack a lack that a-rod.. and clemens.. although it might just as well sit in the bccg as
I am not sure the clemens market is all that strong

lawnmowerman

The Rickeys look to be graded correctly. All of them show more than one corner touch.

The A-Rod upper right egde/corner area looks to be why the card graded a 7. When a card has a lift along the edge/corner 7 is pretty much always the result.

I really wouldn't waste my time cracking a BCCG/Clemens card

Rogermnj

The clemens are probably worth cracking for a $5 special but the market is so soft on them I am not sure.
The others are all graded correctly and 1 of thehendersons might drop to a 7.

otwcards

The first Henderson has a half grade bump in it and is the only card I would consider submitting (the bottom edge is a bit too choppy to go in a PSA 9 -- not rough -- just choppy). The ARod has too many corner issues as well as a chunk out of the edge in his arm. The Fleer Clemens appears to have a new edge on the right and I doubt the Donruss would pull anything higher than an 8.5.

Bosox1976

I'd crack the Henderson and the ARod. The fleer Clemens looks a little weird on the right edge, and the Donruss will sell better in that holder than in a PSA 8/9 (sadly).

grote15

You have a strong chance at the half point upgrade with the Henderson, definitely worth cracking, as the card would just about double from its present value of $35 if it grades an 8.5. That card looks tailor made for the half point bump, as it's nicer than most 8s but not quite as nice as a 9. Closer to a 9 than an 8, though, IMO.

RonBurgundy

What Mike said.



Ron