Rate My Toner (post yours too)

commoncents123

Here's an idea I have...Maybe it will catch on....Rate my toner 1-10....

1 being horrible artificial tone, to 10 being the most impressive original toning you've ever seen...

..Everyone else show what you have, and we will rate yours too!

CB2597

7-8 Now how about mine?

tightbudget

8

commoncents123

<< <i>7-8 Now how about mine?



>>



Not a roosie fan, but that one catches my eye...I'll give you an 8

coinsarefun

7.5

Stefanie

commoncents123

<< <i>7.5

Stefanie




>>



Wow! 6 for the toning, but 10 for the photography...What is your equipment/setup?

PatchFanatic

8!

Please ignore the fingerprint. *It's in a PCGS MS65 Holder*

lcoopie

8

LeeG

The reverse on that Frankie deserves a 9.

UtahCoin

Mesquite

I think CC123's Morgan reverse is an 8.5 - nice coin!

Here is a reverse to complement Utah's 1973 Canadian Commem.

DJCoinz

Lee's is a 7, Utah's is a 7, and Mesquite's is an 8.

lcoopie

8
I like that dark rim toning,

another franklin previously posted (do I have to say that?)

CommemDude

8...lovely album toning on that Franklin

rainbowroosie

nice commem...8.5 and I grade really hard!

CB2597

SkyMan

Some very attractive toners here.

clarkbar04

CB I rate that reverse toned morgan an 8 and SkyMan that frankie looks like an 8.5 at least!!

Here's my newest endroller, coin is much more vibrant in hand.

DeusExMachina

I give Skyman's Frankie a 8.5.

OneCent

I'll give LeeG's a 9, Lcoopie's reverse a 9 and Skyman's Frankie a 8.5. Awesome toner's in here fella's!

Oh yeah, the capped bust is about an 8.5....

FilthyBroke

That one's at least an 8, DeusEx.

lcoopie

onecent I give 9.5 I think hi score so far
filthybroke 7.5

Sunnywood

This thread gives me a good opportunity to get on my usual soapbox about images of toned coins. Just remember folks, you can have two different images of the same coin, made with different imaging techniques and conditions, that can look completely different. One image can look amazingly fluorescent and colorful, while the other can be dull, washed out, dark and/or lifeless. So you can't really compare coins unless the imaging techniques and conditions are identical. The only thing you can judge about many images of toned coins is whether or not the images are colorful and nice looking.

That having been said, here are a few images of toners. For a change of pace, I am presenting four better date "O"-mint Morgans (yes, that's a '96-O !!)

jmj3esq

7.5 on the Morgan, lcoopie.

Here is mine:

fc

since you only showed one side of the coin i rank it a 4.9 ;-)
seriously though i give that a 7.6. very pretty colors.

Sunnywood

ok ... in response to a PM, I'll give you what you want ....



That's a Morgan; here's a Barber ... and they're both MS68's !!!!



Best,
Sunnywood

DJCoinz

Sunnywood, I'm gonna call the morgan 9.7 and the barber 8.6. Gorgeous.