Home Trading Cards & Memorabilia Forum

How will these FB Rookies grade? Lots of pics

Okay guys, after several months of buying slabs I am preparing my first sub and would like some opinions from the grading experts here! Thanks for your input!

Bob....

Ditka - Need for my set, but will it be worth grading? (Wax stains on the front)
Tarkenton - Same as Ditka
Griese - Already have a deal for one so I am probably not going to send this one in
Jurgenson - Need for set
Adderly - Need for set
Jones - Need for set Small crease on bottom right hand corner
White - Need for set
Newsome - Need for set
Wright - Need for set. 2 soft corners
Payton - Need for set. Has a small print bubble on the right hand side of card. Not visible in photo. How much will this lower the grade?
Taylor - Need for set. Really nice, but has a slightly visible print line.
Jones - Need for set
Swann - Need for set
Schmidt - Need for set
Tippett - Need for set
Huff - Need for set
Nitschke - Need for set
Lilly - Need for set - scratch on upper left corner
Greene - looking for an upgrade - this looks pretty sharp
Hampton - looking for an upgrade
Montana - looking for an upgrade
Harris - looking for an upgrade
Hannah - looking for an upgrade
Campbell - looking for an upgrade
Rice - need for future set
Faulk - need for future set


image

image

image

image

image

image

image

image

Comments

  • CDsNutsCDsNuts Posts: 10,092
    Here are my guesses


    Ditka - Need for my set, but will it be worth grading? (Wax stains on the front) 3
    Tarkenton - Same as Ditka 3
    Griese - Already have a deal for one so I am probably not going to send this one in 4
    Jurgenson - Need for set 4
    Adderly - Need for set 6
    Jones - Need for set Small crease on bottom right hand corner 3
    White - Need for set 7
    Newsome - Need for set 7
    Wright - Need for set. 2 soft corners 6.5
    Payton - Need for set. Has a small print bubble on the right hand side of card. Not visible in photo. How much will this lower the grade? 7
    Taylor - Need for set. Really nice, but has a slightly visible print line. 7
    Jones - Need for set 6
    Swann - Need for set 7.5
    Schmidt - Need for set 4
    Tippett - Need for set 8
    Huff - Need for set 7
    Nitschke - Need for set 7
    Lilly - Need for set - scratch on upper left corner 5
    Greene - looking for an upgrade - this looks pretty sharp 7.5
    Hampton - looking for an upgrade 8
    Montana - looking for an upgrade 8
    Harris - looking for an upgrade 7
    Hannah - looking for an upgrade 8.5
    Campbell - looking for an upgrade 8
    Rice - need for future set 8
    Faulk - need for future set 9 or 10
  • Bottom9thBottom9th Posts: 2,695 ✭✭
    Thanks Lee...based on what I paid for this lot I can live with most of those grades so I hope you're right!
  • CDsNutsCDsNuts Posts: 10,092
    No problem. Make sure that Faulk isn't trimmed or hasn't been recolored in the blue corner. Looks amazingly sharp.
  • perkdogperkdog Posts: 31,917 ✭✭✭✭✭
    The background on that Faulk looks like an acid trip! Nice group of cards Bob, I cant grade raw cards at all so my input wouldnt meen much, all I can say is I hope they grade out well enough to make you happy! Good luck!
  • Bottom9thBottom9th Posts: 2,695 ✭✭
    The Faulk is extra bright due to the flash from the camera - my scanner sucks!
    Believe it or not I picked it up at a garage sale. It's very sharp so we'll I will make sure I double check the size too.
  • To many cards to keep track, but you got some cool looking stuff!

    Giovanni
  • envoy98envoy98 Posts: 4,000 ✭✭
    Ditka - Need for my set, but will it be worth grading? (Wax stains on the front) 4
    Tarkenton - Same as Ditka 5
    Griese - Already have a deal for one so I am probably not going to send this one in 4
    Jurgenson - Need for set 5OC
    Adderly - Need for set 7
    Jones - Need for set Small crease on bottom right hand corner (Stan 7, Deacon 6, not sure which has the crease, but drop it to a 4 at best)
    White - Need for set 7
    Newsome - Need for set 7
    Wright - Need for set. 2 soft corners 6
    Payton - Need for set. Has a small print bubble on the right hand side of card. Not visible in photo. How much will this lower the grade? 7
    Taylor - Need for set. Really nice, but has a slightly visible print line. 7.5
    Jones - Need for set (Stan 7, Deacon 6, not sure which has the crease, but drop it to a 4 at best)
    Swann - Need for set 7.5
    Schmidt - Need for set 5
    Tippett - Need for set 8
    Huff - Need for set 7
    Nitschke - Need for set 6
    Lilly - Need for set - scratch on upper left corner 4
    Greene - looking for an upgrade - this looks pretty sharp 7
    Hampton - looking for an upgrade 8
    Montana - looking for an upgrade (Is this my 8 cracked out? If so, 8.5, if not, then an 8)
    Harris - looking for an upgrade 8
    Hannah - looking for an upgrade 8
    Campbell - looking for an upgrade 8
    Rice - need for future set 8
    Faulk - need for future set 9
  • This is assuming you ask for no qualifiers and receiver no .5's. Also, I think this should be a contest and whoever guesses closest gets to pick the card of their choice to have image because I love that Hannah.

    Huff 6
    Tippett 8
    Lilly 5
    Nitschke 6
    Stan Jones 6
    Charley Taylor 6
    Schmidt 6
    Swann 7
    Payton 8
    Deacon 7
    White 6
    Newsome 7
    Wright 6
    Jurgensen 5
    Hampton 8
    Rice 8
    Adderly 6
    Campbell 7
    Hannah 9
    Harris 8
    Montana 9
    Greene 6
    Griese 4
    Ditka 5
    Tark 5

    Get those wax stains off the front, Jesus, removing a wax stain isn't altering the card it is getting crap off of it.
    Grades bases on your scans so I could not be seeing things and could also think I see things that aren't there. Hope you do well Bob, Good luck.
Sign In or Register to comment.