Options
Look what I got for melt value!
A while back I bought a big pile of silver just above melt (with shipping) on ebay, and this was included.
Any thoughts on grade, and if anything seems particularly wrong (considering the wear)

Any thoughts on grade, and if anything seems particularly wrong (considering the wear)
0
Comments
What say you on grade, F15?
Anything that bodybags it???
Obverse, in the fields to the right of the device look to have three small holes and maybe a scratch.
Rever, going through UN in United. It almost looks like damage, but that is hard to determine by a photo.
Otherwise the surfaces look ok. For a grade I would say, net graded to Good 10 but that is not to say that it would be bb as market acceptable.
Edited to say that now the scratch looks like graphiti, like the letter F, and would bb for that.
<< <i>I just saw a similiar one in a shop last week for 70 bucks. >>
Then considering the price, I'm happy with it in the 1879 spot in my album!
<< <i>must just be the pics but the color is odd. nice find! >>
The color is a rather dark gray, much like the photo. I've weighed the thing to make sure it is not a fake, and the weight is normal. I don't have any other well circulated morgans, so I am not really familiar with the range of looks for well circulated examples. Is the color 'out of normal'?
Nice grab for melt
<< <i>The black stuff on the reverse is a smudge of some sort, but not a mark on the coin itself. There is a scratch that looks like an F on the obverse at just past 3 o'clock, and other lighter scratches and dings, that seem to be normal wear. I don't intend to have teh thing certified, but was curious as to the most likely grade. Basically, whatever it is, I'm fairly happy! >>
Nice score! The black stuff could be a stain from the coin being in contact witha rubber band at one time. See if it comes off with acetone. I think the "F" in the field behind Liberty's head would keep it out of good plastic. I concur with VG10.
Keeper of the VAM Catalog • Professional Coin Imaging • Prime Number Set • World Coins in Early America • British Trade Dollars • Variety Attribution
<< <i>Definitely worth a buck or two above melt.
Considering I sold a guy all the other bulk junk a while after buying these for more than I paid, making this effectively free, I was happy with the deal overal! It may have been thrown into the pile (it showed in the pic) just to drive up prices, but no one took the bait. I was happy to get it, and dump the other junk... though I wish now I still had all the silver... it would have been worth WAY more now!
<< <i>I think the rims/denticles are a tad too weak and the cotton bolls just too flat for VG10, but I like it as a VG08. >>
Really?
In general I've always associated VG with a flat design, lacking details, where a Fine woudl have moderate or heavy wear, but still have a clear bold design, with the hairline being well defined.
To me, this looked fine, though I admit, I find I have more experience in grading lower MS samples than well worn ones!
I thought damage would net grade it down, perhaps, but in general really thought F15 before any net grading (maybe F12).
Am I that far off?
<< <i>
<< <i>Definitely worth a buck or two above melt.
Considering I sold a guy all the other bulk junk a while after buying these for more than I paid, making this effectively free, I was happy with the deal overal! It may have been thrown into the pile (it showed in the pic) just to drive up prices, but no one took the bait. I was happy to get it, and dump the other junk... though I wish now I still had all the silver... it would have been worth WAY more now! >>
You did very well on an ebay purchase.
I've sent in a lot of XF & under Morgans to PCGS during the last 5 years or so, and the flat areas on the cotton bolls and over the ear, the merged lower leaves, and the weak denticle detail on the obverse from about 9:00 to 11:00 is why I'm inclined to call this coin a VG08. Or at least that's what I'd expect if I sent it in.
<< <i>It used to be that PCGS would not grade a Morgan Fine-12 unless at least parts of the two vertical lines inside both cotton bolls were visible, although I'm sad to see that this is no longer the case.
I've sent in a lot of XF & under Morgans to PCGS during the last 5 years or so, and the flat areas on the cotton bolls and over the ear, the merged lower leaves, and the weak denticle detail on the obverse from about 9:00 to 11:00 is why I'm inclined to call this coin a VG08. Or at least that's what I'd expect if I sent it in.
Good info! Appreciate the details.