Poppage - Graders Not All Evil
gstarling
Posts: 463 ✭✭
I'm pretty happy overall with this submission. Obviously, there are some I'm not super pumped about, but all in all, pretty good.
I'm putting together a 1994 SP Die Cut set so that explains these. I only send in a card I think is a solid 9 with a shot at 10:
Gem 10 1994 SP 167 GEORGE TEAGUE DIE-CUT
Gem 10 1994 SP 40 AUBREY BEAVERS DIE-CUT
Gem 10 1994 SP 30 QUENTIN CORYATT DIE-CUT
Gem 10 1994 SP 28 JIM HARBAUGH DIE-CUT
Gem 10 1994 SP 173 ERIC CURRY DIE-CUT
Gem 10 1994 SP 29 TONY BENNETT DIE-CUT
Gem 10 1994 SP 163 BRETT FAVRE DIE-CUT
NrMt-Mint+ 8.5 1994 SP 14 WILLIAM FLOYD DIE-CUT
Gem 10 1994 SP 42 BEN COATES DIE-CUT
Mint 9 1994 SP 26 BUCKY BROOKS DIE-CUT
MINT 9 1994 SP 25 CORNELIUS BENNETT DIE-CUT
MINT 9 1994 SP 44 MARION BUTTS DIE-CUT
N3: EVIDENCE OF RECOLORATION 1994 SP 3 MARSHALL FAULK FOIL DIE-CUT
Very happy with the grades except for the Faulk. That was a BGS 9 crack and resubmit. I thought it was a solid 9 with an outside shot at a 10. I missed the recoloration and so did Beckett apparently.
I'll bust odd ball boxes every now and then, and lately it has been 1997 Pacific Philadelphia:
Gem 10 1997 PACIFIC PHILADELPHIA 199 ADAM VINATIERI
NrMt-Mint 8 1997 PACIFIC PHILADELPHIA 199 ADAM VINATIERI
Mint 9 1997 PACIFIC PHILADELPHIA PHOTOENGRAVINGS 11 BRETT FAVRE PHOTOENGRAVINGS
Really thought the 8 would be a 9, but I'm very excited about the 10. That card by itself will pay for the submission. Sent the odd ball Favre in hoping for some set registry bidding wars on the bay. It's a really cool card.
A couple of random cards from around the house, disappointed in both:
NrMt-Mint 8 1989 UPPER DECK 1 KEN GRIFFEY JR. STAR ROOKIE
NrMt-Mint 8 1984 TOPPS USFL 52 STEVE YOUNG
I thought the Griffey was 10. I looked at a stack of 10 Griffeys before deciding to send this one in. I must have missed something because it looked flawless to me. Also disappointed in the Steve Young. It was a SGC 96 (9) crack out. I might resend it in.
Pretty good eyeballing, but really bad luck cracking and resubmitting. I'll take submissions like this every time though.
I'm putting together a 1994 SP Die Cut set so that explains these. I only send in a card I think is a solid 9 with a shot at 10:
Gem 10 1994 SP 167 GEORGE TEAGUE DIE-CUT
Gem 10 1994 SP 40 AUBREY BEAVERS DIE-CUT
Gem 10 1994 SP 30 QUENTIN CORYATT DIE-CUT
Gem 10 1994 SP 28 JIM HARBAUGH DIE-CUT
Gem 10 1994 SP 173 ERIC CURRY DIE-CUT
Gem 10 1994 SP 29 TONY BENNETT DIE-CUT
Gem 10 1994 SP 163 BRETT FAVRE DIE-CUT
NrMt-Mint+ 8.5 1994 SP 14 WILLIAM FLOYD DIE-CUT
Gem 10 1994 SP 42 BEN COATES DIE-CUT
Mint 9 1994 SP 26 BUCKY BROOKS DIE-CUT
MINT 9 1994 SP 25 CORNELIUS BENNETT DIE-CUT
MINT 9 1994 SP 44 MARION BUTTS DIE-CUT
N3: EVIDENCE OF RECOLORATION 1994 SP 3 MARSHALL FAULK FOIL DIE-CUT
Very happy with the grades except for the Faulk. That was a BGS 9 crack and resubmit. I thought it was a solid 9 with an outside shot at a 10. I missed the recoloration and so did Beckett apparently.
I'll bust odd ball boxes every now and then, and lately it has been 1997 Pacific Philadelphia:
Gem 10 1997 PACIFIC PHILADELPHIA 199 ADAM VINATIERI
NrMt-Mint 8 1997 PACIFIC PHILADELPHIA 199 ADAM VINATIERI
Mint 9 1997 PACIFIC PHILADELPHIA PHOTOENGRAVINGS 11 BRETT FAVRE PHOTOENGRAVINGS
Really thought the 8 would be a 9, but I'm very excited about the 10. That card by itself will pay for the submission. Sent the odd ball Favre in hoping for some set registry bidding wars on the bay. It's a really cool card.
A couple of random cards from around the house, disappointed in both:
NrMt-Mint 8 1989 UPPER DECK 1 KEN GRIFFEY JR. STAR ROOKIE
NrMt-Mint 8 1984 TOPPS USFL 52 STEVE YOUNG
I thought the Griffey was 10. I looked at a stack of 10 Griffeys before deciding to send this one in. I must have missed something because it looked flawless to me. Also disappointed in the Steve Young. It was a SGC 96 (9) crack out. I might resend it in.
Pretty good eyeballing, but really bad luck cracking and resubmitting. I'll take submissions like this every time though.
Currently Buying:
2004 Tommie Harris SPX Printing Plate (White Whale will pay top $$$)
1994 SP Football Die Cuts PSA 10s
2004 Tommie Harris SPX Printing Plate (White Whale will pay top $$$)
1994 SP Football Die Cuts PSA 10s
0
Comments
Steve
I just sold my PSA 10 Vinatieri today for $110 BIN.
My eBay Store
BigCrumbs! I made over $250 last year!
<< <i>Nice indeed.
I just sold my PSA 10 Vinatieri today for $110 BIN. >>
That's not bad, I've been tracking this card for about a year, and they go for between $85-$180 depending. I'd be happy to get the money you got.
2004 Tommie Harris SPX Printing Plate (White Whale will pay top $$$)
1994 SP Football Die Cuts PSA 10s