Ugly Tony!

carew4me

Never crack this one ...its a gift at PSA 8

perkdog

Cmon, 3 dinged corners arent that bad!

SOM

No wonder the "Old 8's" are fetching premiums!

otwcards

Obviously a toss-up between a 6.5 and an 8. Nice to see they're erring on the side of caution ::insert significant levels of sarcasm::

After seeing this, I'm still amazed that so many of my '77 Topps Mexicans got 5's and 6's for very light roller marks (typical with the issue) especially after buying other's 8's with heavier ones! C'mon folks. All we ask is consistency (and reasonable turnaround times).

1420sports

that is a PSA 5

jradke4

see they really can grade on a 0.5 scale. what a joke. but then again i am not hearing if the grade doesnt fit you must resubmit crowd. i quess its only resubmit until you get the best grade, you dont send one back that is over-graded. if that is an 8 i find it hard to belive some of the 7's that i get back on exquiste cards. they are only 20x's the thickness with almost no corner issues at all, yet i generally only get 7 and 8's out of them. i guess chipping must be a bigger deal then soft corners. after all i know all the hands that have handle all of my exquiste cards were just flining them around after spending a few $100 on the pack.

wolfbear

The grade is a mistake. Sh** happens.
Somebody needs to notify PSA so they can buy it back before this card sells ...