Guess the grade???(updated with actual grades)

BigDaddyBowman

I'm thinking about resubbing these..what do you think they grade?

EagleEyeKid

5.5
5.5
6
6

nightcrawler

5.5
6
6.5
6

prscott933

6
6
6
6.5

Allen

4
5
6
5

bsidegrve

3
4
5
4

mrguby

4,4,4,4

msassin

Baugh 4/5
Groza 5
Bednarik 5/6
Fears 5

1960toppsguy

Not really worth regrading in the condition they are in as there is nothing above a PSA-4. Save your money and rebuy nice ones.

perkdog

Crap shoot between 5 and 6 IMO, their all very nice looking cards no matter what the grade-great centering and eye appeal.

fiveniner

4s up and down.

bluemarlin

<< <i>Crap shoot between 5 and 6 IMO, their all very nice looking cards no matter what the grade-great centering and eye appeal. >>




Couldn't have said it better.

Jake

yawie99

5.5
6
6
6

As others have said, I don't think they're worth resubmitting, unless you just got murdered with 2's and 3's the first time around.

BigDaddyBowman

thanks to everyone for giving their opinion...you have convinced me to keep them "as is." To the naked eye, and even with a magnifying glass, they look ALOT nicer than with the scan, so I though they might get a bump...especially the Fears or Bednarik. The Baugh is already at SGC as I write...I am hoping it gets an even cross over. Here are the grades:

Brick

Solid 4s with the last 2 - 4.5 possible. Still they have great eye appeal regardless of grade.

nightcrawler

I'd put money on getting a bump on the Bednarik.


I'd like to try and do a set of 1950 Bowmans some day.