2006 P Reverse Proof ASE with Rotated Dies

DRG

I had 20 of my unopened ASE Anniversary sets graded by PCGS. The grades were not great although I did get 3 Reverse Proofs in PR70.

As I was checking them out I noticed that 3 of the Reverse Proofs had a rotated reverse die. The rotation is not huge but not slight either. It is probably 12-13 degrees.

I was wondering if anyone else had heard of this happening with the Reverse Proofs and what people think they are worth. They are not the PR70's.

direwolf1972

How about some pics. I have no idea of the value but sounds pretty cool.

mark511

3 70's on the reverse proofs. I think you did quite well!

BECOKA

Even in 69 these sets are still doing well.

Yes there was a few threads on this a year ago where people were claiming rotated dies. Not sure where that ended up though. It might take a few minutes but try doing a search for ASE and rotated or some similar key words.

FLBuffaloHunter

There were quite a few with slightly rotated dies. Unless it is more than 20% I believe it is considered within Mint tolerance.

RayNY2E

I Had several, But Most were Clockwise. I Had ONE that Rotated Counter Clockwise and Even Though i Did'nt Think it Had Enough Rotation, I Sent it To PCGS Anyway. It was A Costly Lesson as they Determined The Rotation was Not Enough To Qualify For The Designation. It's An Anniversary Reverse Proof in PCGS PR69. I'll try to Find The Link i had To Show the Die Rotation Patterns and Minimum Requirements and Post it Back Here. Ray in Florida.
.
Rotated Die Info Link

DRG

<FONT face=Verdana size=1>RayNY2E; </FONT>My coins are exactly the same as the one you have photographed. Is that the coin you are talking about?

57loaded

<< <i>I Had several, But Most were Clockwise. I Had ONE that Rotated Counter Clockwise and Even Though i Did'nt Think it Had Enough Rotation, I Sent it To PCGS Anyway. It was A Costly Lesson as they Determined The Rotation was Not Enough To Qualify For The Designation. It's An Anniversary Reverse Proof in PCGS PR69. I'll try to Find The Link i had To Show the Die Rotation Patterns and Minimum Requirements and Post it Back Here. Ray in Florida.
.
Rotated Die Info Link >>



the one that was rotated counter-clockwise was probably 340 degrees!

that is a cool one as all the slighlty rotated ones i have seen have been clockwise.

i had 30 sets graded awhile back and had 4 PR70's one PR70DCAM and one MS70