Centering Poll

yankeeno7

IF you have to make a choice of a card being either slightly or a lot OC, do you chose the card being OC Top/Bottom or Left/Right?

yankeeno7

Here are a couple of examples....Loth and I were having a discussion and our tastes are completely different on this subject...
OC Top to Bottom


OC Side to Side

lawnmowerman

That's an easy choice for me, top to bottom

yankeeno7

Would it change your mind if the centering issue wasnt so severe?

lawnmowerman

I am picky when it comes to side to side centering. It's the first thing I notice on a card with borders.

Darin

I voted top to bottom. On my favorite set, 75 baseball its just not near as noticeable when they're off top-bottom.
At the time of my vote, it was 13 tb, 1 side to side.

thenavarro

I would choose OC top to bottom. I don't think its as distracting as OC side to side.

Mike

msassin

34-1 after my vote.

ArnyVee

35-1 after my vote.

scooter729

Make that 38-1.

scooter729

Who voted side-to-side? Let's out him and make him conform!

jimq112

T-B for me

Stingray

40-2!! I would take OC T/B

Morgoth

Would this one be considered off center side to side or top to bottom? BTW how did this not get a qualifier?

nam812

Its actually OC both ways, but I know you initially meant from Ted's head to his chin.

WinPitcher

Depends on the set, so i really can't vote for any.

Some sets it looks ok T/B not L/R


Others vice versa.


Steve

WinPitcher

The Williams may be a card that was sent in and had the "No qualifiers' submission on the form.

It likely would have been a Mint 9 OC or an 8OC card.

Steve

Robby

49 to 2 ................. WinPitcher makes a good point thou , but generally , I like my cards centered my L - R .................. Robbie

stown

<< <i>Depends on the set, so i really can't vote for any.

Some sets it looks ok T/B not L/R


Others vice versa.


Steve >>





I voted L/R just because

mkg809

57-3

HighChopper

65-4