PSA Acceptance ??

samspop

Hey all of you eagle-eyes...I need your opinion on these 3 1970 Topps cards. I pulled them from pages in an album of a set I have been slowly putting together for the last 10 years or so. They looked good, but I always struggle with vintage submissions. Are these PSA acceptable...like 8's or higher?

Thanks in advance....

OAKESY25

I say brock has a shot
perry has the corners but not the centering..
I think mccovey is a lay up 7.. outside 8.. proly 7.5

gotsparks09

It's probably just me, but the Brock's right edge looks all messed up. The HR Leaders has some kind of funny tilt...or curved right edge.

The perry looks like a 7, though.

samspop

The cards had a curl to them and I left the scanner lid open to get the black background. I changed the background and was able to flatten out the cards for a more true view...

Now what do you think?

srs1a

FWIW, I think the Brock is a 7 -- LR corner has white showing. I think the other 2 are probably 8's...although all of them might be 7.5's

gotsparks09

<< <i>The cards had a curl to them and I left the scanner lid open to get the black background. I changed the background and was able to flatten out the cards for a more true view...

Now what do you think? >>



Much better. I still think the Perry is a 7...I think the HR leaders is too. The Brock's right edge still looks MC to me, though. The right edge on the Perry looks a little MC too...but I doubt it's enough to get you a qualifier. Just my .02.

RonBurgundy

7's across the board. The Brock may get an 8 depending on whether the tilt is not so harsh that the centering guidelines for an 8 are met.





Ron

CDsNuts

They should be 8s. PSA is not that tough on this set comparitively.

Estil

I too was thinking they look like solid 8 candidates.