This guy waited over a year before submitting his case of 2006-W 3 coin ASE sets!!

Goldbully

Would you be happy after waiting a full year for these results??

Not a 70 in the bunch.

Wow, and an MS67 for one of the Uncs!!!!

At least he got the 20th Ann. desig.






PCGS Link

BTW, if this submittal is from a forum member???.....

BECOKA

Wow, I did not realize the MS70 pops were that low.

These would have brought much stronger money if sold in sealed boxes on e-bay.

19Lyds

Maybe this submitter purchased one of those boxes off of EBay??

TennesseeDave

The 67 and 68's are probably due to the coins spotting in the sealed box.

ahooka454

ouch

66RB

Can he still return them to the mint??

tmcsr69

<< <i>The 67 and 68's are probably due to the coins spotting in the sealed box. >>



Why wouldn't they BB coins with spots?

Goldbully

<< <i>

<< <i>The 67 and 68's are probably due to the coins spotting in the sealed box. >>



Why wouldn't they BB coins with spots? >>







#100 Milk Spots

direwolf1972

Just submitted a 2 pack today myself thats been sitting around sealed since early last year.

direwolf1972

I'm hoping my results come out better than though.

pf70collector

Perhaps PCGS has closed the door on the 70's. They could be seeing alot of their 70's back for spot review. Almost all mine have developed spots.

tightbudget

Sucks.

oreville

I have waited 7 years to submit my 155 buffalo silver proof and unc dollars to PCGS.

Maybe I will wait another 7 years?

mark511

Hope he did not pay 5,000 for the box.

BAJJERFAN

<< <i>Wow, I did not realize the MS70 pops were that low.

These would have brought much stronger money if sold in sealed boxes on e-bay. >>



It just means that someone else would have bought the problem. Luckily for him none of the coins had milk spots, but now that we know about when those cert numbers were graded we can get some idea of how long it takes to spot if spotting does indeed occur.

FWIW he could have listed them differently on the submission form and had 10 sets each with consecutive cert numbers.

notwilight

Maybe the box has been kicking around on the floorboard of the pickup for years and some of the coin came out of the capsules. --Jerry

BobGreene

When people submit batches of moderns straight from the mint and get upset because they didn't get any 70s, I find it very difficult to feel sorry for them.

shuckins

FWIW he could have listed them differently on the submission form and had 10 sets each with consecutive cert numbers

would that bring a premium?

57loaded

<< <i>
FWIW he could have listed them differently on the submission form and had 10 sets each with consecutive cert numbers. >>



yeah i was going to do that, but you need to list every coin individually, and i don't have the patience for it and did it ever mean anything?

PerryHall

Any one know what the still sealed boxs of ten sets are bringing on eBay these days?

FloridaBill

This is the last 4 trades on eBay for Judas Boxes...

Price eBay number Transaction date and time Seller feedback # Seller feedback rating


$4,499.00 320203668360 Jan-04-08 19:09:02 4594 99.7%
$4,800.00 160197426657 Jan-17-08 18:30:00 90 100.0%
$4,970.00 190191333864 Jan-22-08 15:58:00 876 99.8%
$4,849.00 330205743745 Jan-27-08 17:15:00 89 100.0%

FloridaBill

BAJJERFAN

<< <i>FWIW he could have listed them differently on the submission form and had 10 sets each with consecutive cert numbers

would that bring a premium? >>



Couldn't hurt since it wouldn't cost any more to do it one way vs the other. It might bring a small premium as it would indicate that each coin came from the same set as opposed to cherrypicking a bunch of different sets.

segoja

That has to be the worst grades for that series I've seen

garsmith

ouch, looks like they would have done beter to sell them raw unopened

BAJJERFAN

<< <i>ouch, looks like they would have done beter to sell them raw unopened >>




Hindsight remains at 20/20.

57loaded

<< <i>

<< <i>FWIW he could have listed them differently on the submission form and had 10 sets each with consecutive cert numbers

would that bring a premium? >>



Couldn't hurt since it wouldn't cost any more to do it one way vs the other. It might bring a small premium as it would indicate that each coin came from the same set as opposed to cherrypicking a bunch of different sets. >>



i do see that there could be a market out there. i wanted to show in my auction that the cert numbers were 10 diigits off as it was a full case submission. it may have helped, never kept track, then the spots hit and the whole thing went south

YaHa

Resealed boxes from Mint from returns. Some people know how to look at coins and grade them, they had to be resends.