Request Opinion: Which Hack Wilson Goudey PSA 8 Is "Better"

JackWESQ

So back on December 9, 2007, buyer ebrehm purchased a 1933 Goudey Hack Wilson PSA 8 for $2,251.69 S/N 90049868 (pictured on the left) here:

1933 Goudey Hack Wilson PSA 8 for $2,251.69.

Apparently, ebrehm already (or subsequently picked up one) had a PSA 8 because he has one up for auction here, S/N 07086474 (pictured on the right):

1933 Goudey Hack Wilson PSA 8 for Auction

My question is which one do you think looks better? I think the one on the left looks clearly better, but that just me. It would be interesting to see if the one for auction goes for more than $2,251.69. Your thoughts? Thanks.

/s/ JackWESQ

nam812

Is this a trick question? You really need us for this one?

msassin

<< <i>Is this a trick question? You really need us for this one? >>





I still think the one up for auction hits at least $2000.

WinPitcher

I like the one on the left.


Steve

Leiascards

The one on the left looks better, but the scan appears to be lighter than the one on the right so that makes it hard to tell.

bluemarlin

Hands down the one on the left.

Jake

Stingray

#1 no doubt!!

bifff257

I like #211,,,,




No doubt the one one the left is the one I would pick.